Academia.eduAcademia.edu

Outline

KV 20 and KV 38: Two Tombs attributed to Tuthmosis I

Abstract

This paper examines the architecture and location of two of the oldest royal tombs in the Valley of the Kings: KV20 and KV38. In KV20, sarcophagi for both Hatshepsut and Tuthmosis I have been discovered. In KV38, another sarcophagus was found, also with the names of Tuthmosis I. The attribution by Hayes (“Royal Sarcophagi of the XVIIIth Dynasty”) of the various sarcophagi is examined, and to some extent modified. The plan of KV20 has long defied explanation. The supposed orientation of KV20 towards Hatshepsut’s mortuary temple at Deir el-Bahri is now checked against a satellite picture: this shows matters to be somewhat different than expected. Carefull mapping of both KV20 and KV38 reveals, that both tombs are in fact oriented towards El Qurn: the distinctive mountain peak that dominates the Valley of the Kings. 95 pages, 17 figures, 24 tables, extensive bibliography.

Key takeaways
sparkles

AI

  1. KV20 and KV38 represent significant royal tombs attributed to Tuthmosis I in the Valley of the Kings.
  2. Careful mapping reveals both tombs are oriented towards El Qurn, contrary to previous assumptions about their alignment.
  3. KV20 contains sarcophagi for both Hatshepsut and Tuthmosis I, indicating a complex burial history.
  4. The evidence suggests Hatshepsut likely transferred Tuthmosis I's burial from KV38 to KV20 during her reign.
  5. A total of four burials are identified across KV20 and KV38, reflecting the tumultuous royal lineage.

References (5)

  1. See 3TA, chapter 5, and Fig. 1 in Rose 2000. Altenmüller explicitly favors the conclusions from his table over those of a visual ap- praisal of the plans. On one and the same page (KNR 32), he first acknowledges a clear and unbroken evolution of the royal tombs in the Valley of the Kings from KV38 to KV43 (Tuthmosis IV), provided one ignores KV20 and WA D: Werden die beiden Grabanlagen der Hatschepsut (QV, KV 20) zunächst außer acht gelassen, erkennt man mit absteigender Königsfolge von Thutmosis I. (KV 38) bis hin zu Thutmosis IV. (KV 43) eine kontinuierliche Weiterentwicklung der Grabanlagen, die sich in einer Vermehrung der Raumeinheiten abzeichnet. 224
  2. But just a few lines below this, he states that the scheme nevertheless shows that KV20: …eine weiter entwickelte Form aufweist als das Grab Thutmosis" I. (KV 38), so daß eine Spätdatierung der Architektur des Grabes Thutmosis" I., etwa in die Zeit 220 R/W p. 91.
  3. Hartwig Altenmüller, Bemerkungen zu den Königsgräbern des Neuen Reiches. SÄK 10 (1983), p. 25- 38 (hereafter referred to as KNR).
  4. For a brief description of this interesting tomb, see R/W p. 94, or the website of Karl Leser: http://www.maat-ka-ra.de/. See also note 115 on page 36 above. 223 KNR p. 30, n. 21.
  5. "If one begins with excluding both tombs of Hatshepsut (QV, KV 20), one recognizes with the order of the kings, from Thutmosis I (KV 38) all the way to Thutmosis IV (KV 43) a continuously ongoing devel- opment of the tombs, showing in an increase of rooms" (KNR p. 32).

FAQs

sparkles

AI

What are the main architectural features of KV20 and KV38?add

The paper reveals that KV20 features winding corridors and irregular chambers, contrasting with KV38's cartouche-shaped burial chamber, typical of royal tombs.

What evidence supports the identification of KV38 as Tuthmosis I's tomb?add

KV38 contains a stone sarcophagus inscribed for Tuthmosis I and a canopic box, discovered in 1899, linking the tomb directly to him.

How did Hatshepsut’s reign influence tomb design in KV20?add

Hatshepsut's rule prompted significant architectural advancements in KV20, including planned alignment with her mortuary temple and enhanced chamber designs.

What roles did Tuthmosis II and III play in the burial transitions?add

Tuthmosis III moved Tuthmosis I's burial from KV20 to the newly refurbished KV38, indicating a deliberate shift of royal remains.

How does the research rectify earlier misconceptions about these tombs?add

The findings challenge previous attributions, suggesting KV38 was not originally Tuthmosis I's tomb but was remodeled under Tuthmosis III for reburial.

About the author
Image
Papers
17
Followers
326
View all papers from Sjef Willockxarrow_forward