My first year exposed to the full wonder that is Yuletide, and I am LOVING this rare fandoms thing. So. A few recs from the slushpile:
This Town We're Painting (St. Trinian's/Sherlock BBC crossover). Premise: Kelly Jones takes a job with a "minor employee of Her Majesty's government" who just happens to (a) have a famous detective brother and (b) rule the known world. Hiring people like Kelly is, of course, how he stays on top, and really, what he's after is the entire St. Trinian's old-girl network. You don't have to know either canon well to love this; you just have to appreciate the traveling sisterhood of BAMF women. Oh, and did I mention hot Annabelle/Kelly femslash? That too.
Sparrow (Tale of Genji). A missing scene that takes place during Genji's exile: an accidental encounter between Murasaki and To no Chujo. The tone of the original prose is elusive and very difficult to capture -- the way nature is evoked, the use of poetry, the significance of clothing and objects, the characters who speak through screens both real and metaphorical. This writer has caught it perfectly, and also exposed the raw longing beneath the surfaces of convention. For any lover of the original (and this is one of my favorite stories of all time), this is sublime.
Revels (Lymond Chronicles - Dorothy Dunnett). There's an excellent crop of Lymond stories this year, but this one -- a set of missing scenes from Pawn in Frankincense, exploring how Francis gains Khaireddin's trust -- is the one that affected me the most. Not least because of a sly bit of running quotation from a later part of the series, reminding us that to love is very often, also, to lose. Beautifully done.
De casibus vivorum illustrium (15th Century CE RPF: Niccolò Machiavelli, Cesare Borgia). Fortuna is proverbially fickle, and two of the more notorious moral relativists of the period drink to and wager on her vagaries. A light touch and a deceptively resonant story, set against the backdrop of one of the period's terrible battlegrounds.
Two Men in a Boat (Our Mutual Friend, Charles Dickens). The Eugene/Mortimer bond, here given all the astringent humor and hidden depths of the original, but with the slash subtext fully and movingly unpacked. Anyone who finds Mortimer as attractive a character as I do will be filled with glee at this; as the writer notes, the canon story takes us much of the way. There's also a beautiful play here with boats and river journeys, which loom so large in the book and series, and which underpin this story in an equally fateful but subtler way.
Harriet and Sergeant (Lord Peter Wimsey - Dorothy L. Sayers). I note that this fandom scarcely needs a plug -- it's clearly been a popular one both for writers and readers -- but I particularly liked this story for exploring the dangerous waters of the Harriet-Bunter-Peter relationship. Framing the story with the aftermath of Crutchley's execution in Busman's Honeymoon, the narrative is very much about class roles and how they shape intimate relations -- the bond between the old retainer and the new wife being the most complicated of all. I loved Harriet's POV in this, but especially admire how spot-on Peter's voice is.
Hmm. Class subtext much in all of these? Privilege and constraint? That's a topic for another post.
This Town We're Painting (St. Trinian's/Sherlock BBC crossover). Premise: Kelly Jones takes a job with a "minor employee of Her Majesty's government" who just happens to (a) have a famous detective brother and (b) rule the known world. Hiring people like Kelly is, of course, how he stays on top, and really, what he's after is the entire St. Trinian's old-girl network. You don't have to know either canon well to love this; you just have to appreciate the traveling sisterhood of BAMF women. Oh, and did I mention hot Annabelle/Kelly femslash? That too.
Sparrow (Tale of Genji). A missing scene that takes place during Genji's exile: an accidental encounter between Murasaki and To no Chujo. The tone of the original prose is elusive and very difficult to capture -- the way nature is evoked, the use of poetry, the significance of clothing and objects, the characters who speak through screens both real and metaphorical. This writer has caught it perfectly, and also exposed the raw longing beneath the surfaces of convention. For any lover of the original (and this is one of my favorite stories of all time), this is sublime.
Revels (Lymond Chronicles - Dorothy Dunnett). There's an excellent crop of Lymond stories this year, but this one -- a set of missing scenes from Pawn in Frankincense, exploring how Francis gains Khaireddin's trust -- is the one that affected me the most. Not least because of a sly bit of running quotation from a later part of the series, reminding us that to love is very often, also, to lose. Beautifully done.
De casibus vivorum illustrium (15th Century CE RPF: Niccolò Machiavelli, Cesare Borgia). Fortuna is proverbially fickle, and two of the more notorious moral relativists of the period drink to and wager on her vagaries. A light touch and a deceptively resonant story, set against the backdrop of one of the period's terrible battlegrounds.
Two Men in a Boat (Our Mutual Friend, Charles Dickens). The Eugene/Mortimer bond, here given all the astringent humor and hidden depths of the original, but with the slash subtext fully and movingly unpacked. Anyone who finds Mortimer as attractive a character as I do will be filled with glee at this; as the writer notes, the canon story takes us much of the way. There's also a beautiful play here with boats and river journeys, which loom so large in the book and series, and which underpin this story in an equally fateful but subtler way.
Harriet and Sergeant (Lord Peter Wimsey - Dorothy L. Sayers). I note that this fandom scarcely needs a plug -- it's clearly been a popular one both for writers and readers -- but I particularly liked this story for exploring the dangerous waters of the Harriet-Bunter-Peter relationship. Framing the story with the aftermath of Crutchley's execution in Busman's Honeymoon, the narrative is very much about class roles and how they shape intimate relations -- the bond between the old retainer and the new wife being the most complicated of all. I loved Harriet's POV in this, but especially admire how spot-on Peter's voice is.
Hmm. Class subtext much in all of these? Privilege and constraint? That's a topic for another post.
no subject
Date: 2010-12-29 02:45 am (UTC)BRB reading. :D
no subject
Date: 2010-12-29 02:54 am (UTC)no subject
Date: 2010-12-29 02:47 am (UTC)I LOVE MORTIMER. There's some really gratuitous analysis of Our Mutual Friend in my dissertation, simply because I wanted a chance to talk about him. In, er, the context of class privilege and constraint, yes. (Sorry, I seem always to be talking about my academic work... but this is the fun part, not the OMG STRESS part.)
I am babbling and I haven't even read the fic yet... brb.
no subject
Date: 2010-12-29 02:57 am (UTC)(And you should know by now that this is a safe space for literary geekdom and diss babble of all sorts. And gratuitous OMF references make everything better!)
no subject
Date: 2010-12-29 04:06 am (UTC)I think Mortimer is my Ianto--the quiet, competent, funny, easily-ignored secondary character, who is actually secretly motivated by INTENSE, ALL-CONSUMING LOVE. You know that cute picspam series, The Ianto Show? I have a mental version of OMF which is the Mortimer Show, with all his brief appearances underlined in hearts and sparkles. (The funny thing is that I'm actually content for TW to be about Jack and Gwen, and not the Ianto Show...)
a safe space for literary geekdom and diss babble of all sorts
Aww, thanks! I do know that, but I sometimes still feel like I should be contributing more fun fannish things (fic and meta) on LJ, rather than just taking the chance to muse further on my usual academic topics from a fannish angle. But I guess it's all about whatever floats our boat (no pun initially intended), and I'm lucky to find some other wonderful people to share the boat. <3
no subject
Date: 2010-12-29 02:56 pm (UTC)The point about Lizzie is an interesting one. I'm inclined to think that she would accept the Mortimer/Eugene bond without questioning it too closely; it's such an intensely homosocial period for men, and these two are not in the least unusual in either their long co-habitation or their confidential closeness. It's clearly an affective intimacy every bit as important as Eugene's love for Lizzie; I liked how he speaks of "half his heart" belonging to each. Sex or no sex, that's the evident truth of the story. But it's not hard to imagine the sex part. :)
no subject
Date: 2010-12-29 04:53 am (UTC)Can't wait to read! Meanwhile cannot believe that I have never read Our Mutual Friend and thus will probably not enjoy the awesomely titled Two Men in A Boat
no subject
Date: 2010-12-29 02:48 pm (UTC)no subject
Date: 2010-12-29 10:19 pm (UTC)no subject
Date: 2010-12-30 01:14 am (UTC)I'm going back and forth between the recs page and the fandoms page:http://archiveofourown.org/collections/yuletide2010/fandoms
Such a blast, really!
no subject
Date: 2010-12-30 01:24 am (UTC)