pellucid: (Moya)
Snowflake Challenge promotional banner with image of mug of hot chocolate with marshmallows and gingerbread cookies. Text: Snowflake Challenge January 1-31.

I'm a few days late, posting challenge responses in tandem, and once again jumping on the January bandwagon in that oh so January way. But these were fun!

Challenge #2: Talk about your fannish origin story.

It was 1999. I had been an avid devotee of The X-Files for some years, but in the way of someone who has appointment television.

I was also fairly new to the idea of the internet in 1999, a little later than many: pre-college (I started in 1998), the internet was a fairly public thing. Short forays in the school computer lab, shared time on the home computer with my family. I got my first personal email address as a college freshman, and in 1999 was just coming to an awareness that you might use the internet for things other than schoolwork or IM-ing your now-long-distance friends from high school.

Anyway, some random day in 1999 I was trying to remember some detail from a previous X-Files episode, and it occurred to me that the internet might have, like, episode summaries. I did find that! And in the process also discovered that People. Wrote. Stories. About. Mulder. And. Scully. Mind bloooooooown!!! It had extremely never occurred to me that this could be a thing. College sophomore me was adorable.

College sophomore me was also busy and did not have an internet habit at all. So although I enjoyed discovering that fanfic existed, it was also the kind of thing that I would think about for a little while, and then drop for months at a time, and so forth.

Fast-forward to 2002 or 2003. I was starting grad school, developing more internet habits broadly, and still having a lot of feelings about X-Files season 9. I began to be more deliberate about finding fannish places (the Yahoo groups era?!?) and started to meet some people and even wrote a few terrible fics about Monica Reyes (mercifully now disappeared from the internet, to the best of my knowledge). By 2004 I had an LJ and had discovered Stargate, and the rest was history?

Challenge #3: Talk about a fannish opinion you hold that has changed over time.

More of an opinion about fandom, which has clearly coincided with the broader mainstreaming of fandom. Back in the 2000s when I was most active in fandom, I DID NOT talk about it with real life people. When I went to Dragon Con in 2006 I had a whole network of half truths ("seeing friends!") to avoid telling my roommates and my family where I was actually going. I watched Farscape, BSG, and Babylon 5 with one of my closest friends and never ever told her I was also spending hours a week at the same time reading and writing fic and talking about these shows with people on the internet.

Somewhere along the way, I loosened up a lot of that paranoia. Not long ago I told all of my colleagues that [personal profile] gabolange and I met in BSG fandom, even though for years we had a well-honed "through mutual friends" version of that answer. I have had plenty of other conversations about fandom with non-fandom people in the past decade or so. All that paranoia from years back about streams crossing feels much more distant now.

Sort of. I still carefully avoid any public connection of my RL identity and fannish pseud. I have never confessed to writing fic to a non-fan. Some things change, but perhaps some of us will to some extent always be products of our fannish coming of age eras!
pellucid: (there is no normal life)
One of the snowflake challenge things, which I now can't be fussed to go back and find the number of, or to post the snowflake banner, was five things. Any five things! Which is somewhat overwhelming, because there are so many topics about which one might have five things, so how am I supposed to just randomly pick something?

And then I thought: five things I took for granted before chronic illness. Followed quickly by: no, that's depressing, and not in the spirit of the fandom thing, etc. But I've continued to think about it, so here goes.

1. Planning things

The planners I like come in six-month intervals, and they have stuff at the beginning where you're supposed to lay out goals and interim steps, and I can only barely just start to do this a little bit for the next six months. With small things. Otherwise, the future is just sort of this blank unknown. Before I got sick, I was planning within a couple of years to move on from my job and leave this town that I really don't like. But now I'm just damned lucky to still be employed and have no idea when I might have the wherewithal to deal with new things and places. Even stuff like travel: what will I be capable of in six months? Who knows! Meh.

2. Not planning things

Things that are no longer part of my life: spontaneity, going with the flow, not having a plan for where and how I will rest at regular intervals. I like my family and have always enjoyed big family gatherings well enough, but the recent holiday visit was awful because everything was sooooo unstructured, and I was basically wrecked after about 2.5 days of that.

3. A second wind

I only get one wind. On a good day. No second winds or third winds or pushing through because you want to do the thing or need to do the thing or are in the middle of something that's turning out to last way longer than expected.

4. Procrastinating

Formative memory: in the fourth grade, I did not adequately prepare for the science fair and had to stay up until whatever counted as really late in the fourth grade doing a frantic, slapdash job to finish it. Except then I won the science fair. (It turns out actually understanding the scientific method trumps a fancy poster thingie.) And so began a pattern of procrastination that characterized the next 30+ years of my academic and professional life. It always got done in the end, and it was always pretty damned good, but what a boom and bust cycle. I am no longer physically capable of this, and I remain terrified that I won't be able to work without it.

(Though we have determined that what was always basically sub-clinical ADHD now rises to the level of clinical because my coping mechanisms no longer work, and adderall is magical, y'all.)

5. Independence

I don't think I ever necessarily set out with the idea that independence--financial or otherwise--was an important goal or value. I was just that person who struck out on my own as a young adult and put myself through grad school and stayed single and lived alone and took care of my own damned self, so independence was more habit than anything else. But there's nothing quite like the looming very real possibility of dependence, for the first time since college, in one's 40s to make independence look really fucking important. And I was doubly lucky: first, that I dodged that bullet (at least so far) and have kept my job and my house and my 401k and all the rest; and second, that I do have people I could become dependent upon, should that have become necessary. But I'm never going to take it all for granted again, that's for sure.

Well then. If anyone wants five more uplifting things, fannish or otherwise, do feel free to prompt me!
pellucid: (reading sunshine)
Snowflake Challenge promotional banner with image of metallic snowflake and ornaments. Text: Snowflake Challenge January 1-31.

I do appreciate the snowflake challenge's approach of "do whichever of these you want, whenever you want." Very much in my current wheelhouse. This one looked like fun, and it gives me a chance to talk about Russ and Clare: share a favourite piece of original canon (a show, a specific TV episode, a storyline, a book or series, a scene from a movie, etc) and explain why you love it so much.

My main media consumption for the past year+ has been mystery series on audiobook. On one hand, there is sort of a never-ending supply of this sort of thing. On the other hand, most of what I've read has been no better than average, and it turns out I have some fairly specific criteria that can be challenging to search for. Not too violent (which basically rules out anything labeled "thriller"), not too cozy (that is, needs to give due attention to the gravity of solving murders), decently written, and--this is the kicker--ideally fairly character-driven. It's very easy for the detective protagonist(s) in this genre to turn into little more than plot exposition mouthpieces; I want books that are about the characters. If there's a slow burn ship, who am I to complain. Oh, and because my audiobook budget is limited, especially for mystery series I'm going to burn through, my library needs to have them.

The one series that has ticked all the boxes and then some--by being not just being about the characters but by creating characters who are layered and nuanced and people I really like--is the Clare Fergusson and Russ Van Alstyne series by Julia Spencer-Fleming.

I quite like Russ, mostly because he is sort of the antithesis of the silent and emotionally repressed police officer that is such a common trope. He is, for the most part, self-aware and comfortable in his own skin, as well as compassionate and happy to let other people be smart and right. All with enough flaws and blind spots to keep him from being too perfect or idealized. (To compare him to a more famous detective from a series that's a solid almost for me, he's got a lot of Armand Gamache's good points without all the obnoxious too-perfect, always-right-ness of Gamache.)

But mostly I love Russ because he loves Clare, and Clare is the main reason I'm here.

Clare is an Episcopal priest who is very good at this in the ways that really count and also really bad at this in a whole host of other ways. I'm an ex-Episcopalian with very complicated feelings about Christianity and a lifelong love of characters with religious convictions who are portrayed realistically, so Clare had me at hello. She, too, is a compelling mix of compassion and conviction and flaws and blind spots, similar enough to Russ that they click instantly, different enough to be narratively interesting. Her storyline is also very much about the complexities of finding home and about how much of yourself you can shed and remake--or not--when you uproot your life. So basically, big flashing [personal profile] pellucid buttons. And then she goes and falls in love with a married man, which becomes a really fascinating thing to watch her negotiate in the context of her faith and vocation.

Beyond the main characters, the books, set in upstate New York, have a really strong sense of place, which I always love. (Though let's not talk about the amount of time I've spent on Google maps trying to figure out precisely where this fictional town is supposed to be. Some of the internal references to real places are contradictory...) There are some lovely and well-rendered supporting characters. The mysteries are for the most part well-developed and multi-faceted, neither too obvious nor too out of left field. And the writing is consistently quite good. Also, if you're an audiobook fan, the narrator is phenomenal.

And I don't know if this is a big caveat or an ultimate selling point, but over the course of the series, she deploys two of my absolute most hated tropes--each in a pretty big way--and while I definitely wasn't happy about it, it didn't keep me from continuing to read and enjoy. I think the thing that saved it, in both cases, was the willingness to commit to the implications. Yes, [obnoxious and in one case rather problematic trope] happened, but then there was a commitment to thinking about what these particular characters would do in this situation, in response to this set of circumstances. I mean, I still have canon divergence AUs running in my head for both situations, and if I should ever find myself in a fic-writing inclination for this, we're definitely going to fix the first thing. But handled differently I would have probably stopped reading, and i didn't, so take that as you will.

So that's my current love in search of a fandom. There are a handful of AO3 stories, which is better than none, but if anyone wants to actually come talk to me about these books, I would be delighted.
pellucid: (Eye)
In an effort not to pop up, post once, and then go away again for god knows how long, I thought it might be useful to engage with the snowflake challenge. But the problem with fandom things when you've been so far out of fandom is figuring out where to even start. There's something so magical about the kind of community that comes about when a bunch of people share this wild, irrational love for something. But when there's no something at the center, when you're so far in between wild, irrational loves that it's almost hard to remember what it was like, then it's hard to see a way in.

So I guess my fandom wish for this year, insofar as I have one, is to find a fandom community again. It's a taller order than I ever would have thought, back in the day. To find a thing to love enough to want to engage with in that way, for it to be a thing that other people also love enough to engage with in that way, and--here's the particular rub for me at this moment--to have enough energy and cognitive wherewithal to actually do the engaging. In a fannish context where most of this engagement is happening on platforms that my brain can't really deal with right now.

Barring the big new fandom love thing, some slightly more specific things on the fannish wish list:

I've been thinking, as I continue to do from time to time, about the stupid fucking tragedy of Janet Fraiser. I suppose we all have those character deaths that we'll never really get over. The internets tell me that the TWENTIETH anniversary of the "Heroes" episodes is coming up next month. Jesus, what is time. But I also continue to live in the firm belief that nope, absolutely never happened, and Janet just happened to be offscreen for the last three seasons. Which leads me to the wish list. Janet Fraiser and Cam Mitchell. Such a shame they didn't intersect. Except in my alternate timeline they obviously did, and I would really love for some fic about them to exist.

Watching things has been hard on my brain, and reading challenging things has been hard on my brain, but the one thing I've been able to do a lot of while sick is listen to relatively formulaic audiobooks. Mystery is my genre of choice, preferably in long series so I don't have to make new decisions about what to read next. Most of what I've read has been extremely forgettable, but I have fallen rather in love with the Clare Fergusson and Russ Van Alstyne series by Julia Spencer-Fleming. In a way that makes me really, really wish there were a fandom. So the other thing on my wish list is another person or three to love Russ and Clare with.

*taps mic*

Jan. 1st, 2024 01:00 pm
pellucid: (there is no normal life)
Um, hello! Apparently I have not posted since 2018, which is now somehow SIX years ago? But I guess there has been some stuff going on.

My (more recent-ish) stuff specifically: I have long covid, 16 months and counting. For me this has looked like chronic fatigue (I now have an official me/cfs diagnosis) with a side of traumatic brain injury. There were a number of months of full-time disability leave, followed by a number of more months incrementally clawing my way back to full-time work, which I have been doing, with heavy ADA accommodations, since September. So obviously that has all been super fun.

The good news is that I am (very, very slowly) improving, and I have been able to remain employed (thereby maintaining my medical care, because this country is dreadful) and to keep living independently. Much gratitude for my very supportive employer, as well as for friends and family for helping to prop up the independent living thing when everything was at its worst.

Still, this has been super isolating. In-person interactions remain extremely draining, and it's hard to have energy for much of anything after most of my available effort has gone to work stuff. And as a consequence of my brain being somewhat broken, I'm not really able to process the pace of 2020s-style online social interactions. Lots of scrolling, rapid-fire, multi-media and multi-thread stuff to process, basically your average day on tumblr or a busy discord server: very much a no-go. Does that make DW the broken brain equivalent of slow internet (a la "slow food" or whatever, not "lousy connection"), or going analog(-ish)? Maybe. Worth giving it a whirl, anyway. Because I do miss being able to engage with screen friends!

Not clear what I will be engaging about, to be clear. Broken brain also doesn't really like TV, and it's been a good long time since I've felt super fannish about anything. Generalized good feelings about all things Star Trek is as close as I'm getting lately--while also having failed to watch the last episode of Lower Decks for however long it's been since it aired. Peak nostalgia s3 Picard was right up my alley in terms of what my brain is able to deal with. I found s2 of Strange New Worlds extremely underwhelming (and heteronormative, ugh) after s1, though I was admittedly much healthier for s1. I will love Kathryn Janeway forever (but also fizzled out on an attempted Voyager rewatch). Idk. That's about what I've got. I mostly just read shitty mystery book series now (and occasionally some not so shitty ones).

But this *gestures vaguely* feels worth a shot, anyway. Hopefully some of the screen friends are still out there! (I have been lurk-reading DW off and on, even if I haven't been posting or commenting much?) And if there are interesting other folks, friends of friends or whatever, who are doing the DW thing these days, maybe make some recs or tell me how we find folks on here these days, especially absent a specific fandom motivator? A 2024 goal: figure out how to have enough energy to have friends. Here goes, I guess!
pellucid: (Jean 3.05)
Posting here largely for record-keeping purposes, but hey, maybe someone will be interested in reading. :)

Miss Fisher's Murder Mysteries and The Doctor Blake Mysteries are set near enough to each other in time, space, and topic that it's pretty easy to imagine these worlds intersecting (though people don't do this nearly as much as one would think/wish). Both shows feature an awesome redheaded queer female pathologist. (Okay, Alice is not canonically queer, but...she also obviously is.) And suddenly this felt like the most obvious and awesome pairing in the world.

To Make the Wounded Whole, Alice Harvey/Elizabeth Macmillan, post-canon for Miss Fisher and pre-canon for Doctor Blake, 3600 words, rated T.

So I have achieved 2018 fic as well as 2017 fic. Woo continuing to fangirl actively and all that.

(Though the flip side of active fangirling: someone totally plagiarized one of my Call the Midwife fics! Which actually has never happened to me before, at least with this kind of egregiousness. Possibly I went a little bit English professor on her ass, and possibly she did not take that particularly well, but she did take down the story.)

And in other Doctor Blake news, [personal profile] gabolange made me a Jean icon for Galentine's Day! *points* Quite possibly my favorite Jean face of all the many excellent Jean faces. (She has an exceptionally good face.)
pellucid: (Moya)
I've been thinking a lot about Farscape fandom lately. (Mostly as a contrast to Call the Midwife fandom, which is...a very long story that you can see some of, if you care to, by poking around on mine and [personal profile] gabolange's Tumblrs, and also on her journal. But as someone who has been around that fandom for a while confirmed to me yesterday, it really is the Stepford fandom.)

But anyway, my experience of trying to enter Stepford/twilight zone fandom, and sort of falling on my face a bit, because the floor isn't where you think it is, has made me think of Farscape, and what a tremendous fandom that was to join. I was late to it--the show had finished--and I was never in the thick of things like so many people were. The fandoms that brought me my lifelong friends were mostly not that one, though of course I know for many people their Farscape crew was what my BSG crew became to me.

But that didn't matter, and that's the brilliant thing. Even a bit on the fringes and late to the party, there was still that recognition of that--thing--that on one hand is true of all fandoms when they grab your heart but was somehow so much more true of Farscape. I'm never going to love anything ever again like I love this. Maybe it's because Farscape is so weird and uneven, and so many people back right out the door, that when it clicks, when it becomes your One True Show, that kindred spirit thing is strong. Back then, someone would discover it and post their first OMG Farscape!!! post. Some friend who was already into the show would see it and call in the puppy pile, and suddenly all these people were flailing about in your comments, showing you where the good fic was, and welcoming you to the fold.

And the fic. God. No other fandom I've known has had such a high proportion of astonishingly brilliant fic. Sure, there was also plenty of bad and mediocre fic, but there was SO. MUCH. good fic. So many amazing writers pushing the envelope at every opportunity, pushing it even further than the show itself, which is saying something.

For me it came at exactly a moment in my life that I needed to fall down that particular wormhole. And maybe if I'd found it at another time it would have been a little different (though I can't imagine any version of me not adoring it). But I'm never going to love anything ever again like I loved that. And I loved it alongside some really amazing people who felt the same way.
pellucid: (Shelagh misty road)
Really, nothing but Call the Midwife thoughts, these days. [personal profile] gabolange and I talked on the phone last weekend for over two hours, and probably an hour and 45 minutes of that was CtM. It's nutso. Active fangirling! Who knew we still had it in us!

So season 6 has now concluded. And partly--thank god? This is the first show I've actively fangirled during a currently airing season in a looooong time, and it was stupidly stressful. I would say that Tumblr is the worst, but actually, I think the UK media tabloids are the actual worst, and then Tumblr just magnifies it. So much crazy sensationalized spoiler stuff leaked to the press so far in advance of the episodes!!! And if some intern at Radio Times didn't get fired at some point, there is no justice in the world.

If my feelings about the experience of watching in real time were largely negative, my feelings about the series itself were spoilers! )

Interestingly, I dealt with my feelings about the Turner plot by writing a story that jumped the queue of several things I'd already been working on, and isn't actually about my own feelings by the time it all got transformed, but it was therapeutic nonetheless. And, um, I wrote a fic. For real, with beta and all that jazz--first time in a very long time. It feels good!

In case anyone is interested: Over the Hills and Far Away, gen, Timothy and Shelagh on family and change, post 6.08.

And because this thing is totally a team endeavor, [personal profile] gabolange also just published a fic that does some season 6 fixing, and it's excellent: Mercy of the Fallen, four conversations that should have happened during 6.04 (Patrick and Timothy, Trixie and Tom, Delia and Shelagh, Shelagh and Patrick)

Of course, [personal profile] gabolange has also been writing me the season 2 Sister Bernadette and Doctor Turner are sneaking around AU, first two parts here and here. In case I'm not the only one who needs really hot and slightly OOC nun sex fic in their lives.
pellucid: (Default)
Last of the writing prompts, a few days late. (And at this point I've sort of given up on both the fic prompts, sorry! [personal profile] daybreak, we shall see on the Sister Bernadette thing. It tried to become a proper fic, and then I realized part of that, but not the part you actually asked about, was actually part of a different fic in the queue, so maybe the part you actually asked for will see fit to become its own ficlet one of these days. But mostly the point of this is I'm actually writing legit fic and have a queue, wtf?!?!? Party like it's 2008, apparently.)

But the last of the prompts not requiring excessive creative juices: [personal profile] gabolange asked for the top five places I'd visit in the world and why. This is surprisingly hard? Partly, I think, because my travel bucket list is as much about regions and combinations and time spent and all that. But hey, why not talk about that, too, I guess! In no particular order:

New Zealand
Because it's gorgeous and you don't have to choose between beaches and mountains! This also feels like a medium-sized, reasonably doable trip? Like, obviously it takes 20+ hours just to get there, so you want to stay for a couple weeks to make the jet lag worth it, but I don't know that it needs to be more than that. Couple days each in Auckland and Wellington, then to the south island for the hiking and the views and the beaches. Ideally there would be whale-watching.

Southern South America
[personal profile] gabolange and I were actually going to do the Peru part of this this summer, before her hip got borked. (Now we're going to Chicago instead--but we're seeing Hamilton, so that's practically like a bucket list trip, right?! :P) But when it comes to South America, I don't actually care a bit about jungle things. I'm sure Brazil is great, and I wouldn't not go, but it isn't a priority. However, Peru, Chile, and Argentina: yessssss! I would love to do a big trip that managed to get in the Andes and the Incan ruins, then Argentinian wines and Buenos Aires, and then total bucket list trip to Patagonia, mostly because it's gorgeous and would be cool to say I'd been to Patagonia. Could probably swing both whales and penguins. In reality this is probably two trips--the Peru trip we were already planning, and a separate Argentina trip.

The Mediterranean Grand Tour
Retirement or sabbatical bucket list trip: minimally across the south of France and Italy, the particularly awesome version would start in Spain and end in Greece, maybe. This is the slow, lazy trip with everything: food and wine, wandering around cathedrals and scenic little villages, cycling in the mountains, more food, more wine, more mountains. Some beaches. More wine.

Nepal
I love mountains. I would like to see the Himalayas before I die.

The Arctic
This has always been a funny fascination for me, because I hate the cold. But of course it isn't winter all the time, and summer in the Arctic has always seemed amazing. The wildflowers and the impossibly huge open spaces. The caribou, the sun that never sets. Narwhals! Among other whales. Various versions of this hold different appeal. In Canada I knew people who would drive from Vancouver to Whitehorse and/or on through to Alaska. I love a good road trip, so that one has always seemed like it would be pretty epic. On the other hand, hard to see whales on a road trip, so there's also a version of this involving the Hudson Bay, or Greenland and the colorful houses, and boats and terrifying little planes. There's also the much more accessible version of this, which just involves going to Alaska like normal people go to Alaska. But that feels perfectly plausible and less bucket-list-y? I would like the bucket list version of this trip to involve thousands of caribou, at least three kinds of whales, and zero overcrowded cruise ships full of tourists.
pellucid: (I will not be afraid of women)
Happy Galentine's Day, all my people!!!! This is absolutely my favorite made up holiday of the year, even if I've mostly been too busy today to appreciate it.

Today for my writing prompt, [personal profile] runawaynun asks me to "Describe the perfect Galentine's Day celebration."

Hmm. On one hand, I'm so easy. Girlfriends, travel, wine. I mean, [personal profile] gabolange and I have actually done this, more or less, the past two years, heading for warmer climes in the winter (Mexico two years ago, and I think we actually hit Galentine's Day that time, Vegas last year, a couple weeks later). So seasonally, travel to warm places seems to be the thing. (This year we're waiting until April and going to Chicago, but whatever.)

Since this is supposed to be "perfect": I don't know, y'all, what warm sunny place do we want to lounge around in some February? I would suggest grabbing [personal profile] gabolange and [personal profile] chaila and [personal profile] runawaynun and [personal profile] beccatoria and all the gang, and going to...Hawaii, maybe? It is peak humpback whale season in Maui this time of year. And there could be hiking and outdoorsy things, for those who want them, and loungy beach things, for those who want that, and brightly colored fruity beach drinks, but also good wine and good food. And whales. So yes. I think girlfriend trip to Hawaii in February would be my perfect Galentine's Day!

**

In other news, I said I would get in the habit of doing Call the Midwife reviews this series. spoilers for 6.04 )
pellucid: (Shelagh misty road)
Hey, I made it a whole week before getting behind schedule! This feels like an accomplishment? Yesterday for writing in February, [personal profile] daybreak wanted an ep review of Sunday night's episode of Call the Midwife. But I've been sick this week, and that just absolutely wasn't happening yesterday. Fortunately, today was an empty day, so I'm now caught up!

So today we are going old-school with a DW/LJ episode review! Party like it's 2008, babies!!! spoilers for Call the Midwife 6.03 )
pellucid: (Sarah/Ellison haaaaaaaands)
Hey, I'm writing in February! Prompts continue to be welcome, if you'd like!

My dear [personal profile] gabolange has started with what has turned out to be a doozie: What is the sexiest story you've ever read and why?

Some backstory: [personal profile] gabolange and I have rather a long fannish history of reading and writing meaty character stories, which maybe sometimes are sexy, but often aren't. But then we fell into Call the Midwife Turner fandom, which is the most vanilla PG fandom I've ever seen, and it's so weird because there are almost no cliche PWP fics, and things aggressively fade to black, and just...whyyyyyy??? And suddenly this genre that we took for granted and therefore didn't care about is rather glaringly absent and we find ourselves plotting to write cliched nun sex fic. Call it a fannish midlife crisis or something.

So in the context of thinking about this genre of stories lacking in this fandom--sexy stories!--what are my criteria for a good sexy story?! Turns out, this is a far more difficult question than I would have thought.

Probably 90% of the time, I just skim the sex scenes in fic. Like...it's the same thing over and over again, get on to the character stuff, please. Also I think a lot of fic I read tends to go in one ear and out the other, more or less, even when I like it. So what happens in the 10% of the time when I sit up and pay attention. I think a) it's really well-written, b) it is part of the character stuff, c) it pushes my ship buttons hard and d) I happen to read it when I'm really into a particular pairing. I've had trouble laying my hands on anything that really fit all those criteria right now--because the well-written character stuff I loved back in the day is for pairings that are only hitting my nostalgia buttons, not my obsessively thinking about them right now buttons. And there is basically no fic hitting current buttons c) and d) that is also well-written and in-character.

(An aside about ship buttons: never fail is "we are crazy about each other but can't act on it because [we work together / one of us is a nun / we used to be married but one of us was a Russian spy who betrayed the other one / one of us is trying to save the world from Skynet and the other is the FBI agent trying to catch her / one of us is the head of a multinational media conglomerate and the other is her assistant and also Supergirl / and so forth]." Desire + chemistry + obstacle = bulletproof ship buttons. The problem with the current ship, of course, is that while the obstacle exists (she's a nun!), there's really no way to do in-character sex, because, yeah, they just wouldn't. So is it possible for a), b), c), and d) for Sister Bernadette and Dr. Turner? Probably not. This is perhaps my other problem with this fandom...)

So basically, the "sexiest story I have ever read" is going to change over time if I'm no longer all that pressingly into that pairing. Is this weird? Does this happen to other people? I guess I should also add that sexy stories don't necessarily have to contain sex (and obviously I don't tend to think the vast majority of stories with sex are all that sexy). It's complicated, basically!

Some permutations:

The first thing I thought of when I considered this prompt was No for Yes by Yahtzee. Alias, Jack and Irina, basically the Jack and Irina story. But on rereading it, I'm not sure it's necessarily a sexy story? It's an excellent, excellent character story. It's well-written. It contains sex (though sex for character building more than sex for sexiness, which is probably an important distinction). I love this pairing forever. So we'll call it one of my favorite stories ever, but not perhaps the sexiest story I've ever read.

Then I thought of [livejournal.com profile] thassalia, who always wrote the beeeeeessssst John/Aeryn back in the day. (Farscape always breaks the rules, doesn't it. John and Aeryn do not really fit my desire + obstacle pattern--I mean, there are various obstacles at various times, but it's different--yet they are always and forever going to be the sexiest otp ever.) And Thea would write these gorgeous little PWP fics that were well-written and in-character and super hot, and they do hold up. Things like Canthas and Against the Grain. So probably these have a much better claim on "sexiest story I've ever read," but at the same time, much as I will love John and Aeryn forever, rereading them was more about remembering when I did find those stories amazingly sexy than feeling that at the time. Nostalgia sexy, not present sexy.

Which leads me back to criterion d) I am really into the particular pairing. And to the one CtM fic that pushes my pairing buttons at this moment when I really care, and is at least moderately well-written and in-character. So possibly the answer to this question for me at this moment, despite having been a fairly discerning reader of fic in a number of fandoms for well over 15 years and therefore having many, many options to choose from, is an unfinished wip on the pit in which there is no sex, and everyone remains excessively well-clothed, but Sister Bernadette and Dr. Turner do a lot of sneaking around to make out and then feel really angsty about it: Whatever Will Be by newyork24-7. IDEK. Possibly I have come back from my accidental hiatus from doing fandom actively for the past few years with my brain slightly broken.

A postscript: the right Sarah Connor/James Ellison story still feels like it would win this contest for all time, but to my knowledge it doesn't exist. Maybe it's the fact that it doesn't exist that keeps the hope alive as presently sexy and not nostalgia sexy. But damn, they are just so hot and perfect.
pellucid: (reading sunshine)
I'm stealing from [personal profile] chaila (and probably some other people) to get back in the habit, I hope, of engaging here. Pick a date in February, give me something to write about, and I'll talk about it: fandom, TV, books, work, dog, travel, life, maybe politics depending on how well I'm dealing with the dumpster fire on any given day, whatever. No promises because I'm REALLY rusty with the fic writing, but if you give me a fic prompt you might even get something of that sort (chances are higher if this is about Sister Bernadette/Shelagh Turner, because that's where my fannish brain is at the moment, but you never know!). Will lock anything personal, but I'm happy to grant access if you don't have it (and you don't seem like some creepy person I don't have some logical fannish connection to!).

So leave a comment with a date and a prompt (or plural, I guess, if you have more than one), and I'll update this post to keep track of everything, and hopefully this will be good for writing habits and engagement here, and so forth. I'll try to keep everything straight across platforms, because I know a number of people are still only at LJ, but if you're in both places, I'd be happier if you comment on the DW post.

February 1:
February 2:
February 3:
February 4: [personal profile] gabolange - What is the sexiest story you've ever read and why?
February 5: [livejournal.com profile] de23 - Tell us all about your current position.
February 6: [personal profile] daybreak - Last night's episode of CtM!
February 7:
February 8:
February 9: [personal profile] kernezelda - What was your most recent pet-related delight, or alternatively, what was the most recent thing or happening that made you grin like a happy loon, and laugh out loud, and brightened your whole day?
February 10: reserved
February 11: [personal profile] chaila - I would really enjoy if someone, hypothetically you, wanted to write us a bit of Cat/James subtext, maybe when she promoted him, or in a perfect world where she never left. ;) Or you know I'm alllllllllways down for some Sarah/Ellison post-canon.
February 12:
February 13: [personal profile] runawaynun - IT'S GALENTINE'S DAY. Describe the perfect galentine's celebration.
February 14: [personal profile] daybreak - The day Sister Bernadette took her vows.
February 15:
February 16:
February 17:
February 18: [personal profile] chaila - I am actually very curious about the new job! I know generally what it is, but what's a typical day like? Or if there's no typical day, a representative day? (I feel like I never know what people actually do at their jobs, and it's interesting to find out).
February 19: [personal profile] fallingtowers - Have you got any cute pictures /anecdotes of your new dog that you'd like to share?
February 20:
February 21: [personal profile] siljamus - A favourite work of art
February 22:
February 23:
February 24: [personal profile] siljamus - Talk about 'home' and what it means to you.
February 25:
February 26:
February 27: [personal profile] gabolange - Top five places you'd like to visit in the world and why.
February 28:
pellucid: (I will not be afraid of women)
So, Supergirl. I've been watching, enjoying, loving Cat Grant liek whoa, because obviously, but it hadn't totally grabbed me. I was really loving what this show was choosing to be, yet somewhat underwhelmed by the balance and execution (could we have a show that is 80% Cat and Kara being badasses in their respective way, 10% James looking really pretty, 10% the rest of it?).

Then I was reminded, a few days ago, that I actually never watched the most recent ep that aired a few weeks ago. And lo, it was awesome, and spoilers for 1.08 ), and I thought, hey, I wonder if there's fic, and THERE IS because sometimes fandom actually does have all the same buttons as I do.

This hasn't happened a lot lately: a recent attempt to get into The 100, for instance, was completely thwarted when I realized my buttons were at odds with fandom and the direction of the show. But y'all, there is a burgeoning little Kara/Cat femslash community (aka SuperCat, because oh fandom, never change), and I have now spent the past two days reading all the fic. Also, it's SuperCat Week, apparently, and people are writing challenge fics to really awful cliches, and it feels like it's 2005, at least in my fandom world.

And beyond the silly fandom cliches, have a rec for a story that isn't that, and isn't actually shippy, particularly, but is about their power dynamics and the ways they are protective and threatening in their respective ways, and a fallout to the most recent episode that feels more realistic than what seems like is going to happen on Monday: I Had to Find the Passage Back (To the Place I was Before).

But here's the other thing: my fangirl has been broken for a while. I've watched things, enjoyed things, had short-lived excitement that even led to wanting to read a little fic or something, but nothing that has really sparked that desire to write or be thinky or finally join Tumblr so that I can have an endless stream of pretty pictures of Calista Flockhart at my disposal. And it's too early to tell whether this one will do that or just be a flash in the pan, but, um, I'm reading really bad fic and watching the five available youtube vids over and over again. So this feels like a good/bad sign, right???!!!
pellucid: (Eye)
It felt more important to write another post (writing practice!) than to answer comments, but xoxoxoxo to you all for comments on the last post. People are still around!

Surgery is WEDNESDAY, which is exciting and a little scary and stressful all at once.

But enough of health stuff.

Last night I was scrolling through Netflix, feeling generally dissatisfied with all of my options, and I suddenly decided that what I needed to do was rewatch some late-season, Doggett- and Reyes-featuring X-Files. IDEK, except I always did love Doggett and Reyes, despite generally being of the opinion that the show would have done better just to end with season 7, or possibly earlier. Nevertheless, I watched a few of the episodes that I remembered as being less terrible than others, was kind of nostalgically charmed by them (though wow, is Annabeth Gish a bad actress, yet I still love Reyes liek whoa despite it).

The more interesting thing, though, was that this made me want to go find some old fic. Of course the particular things I was looking for never made it to Gossamer, and were instead on an old Tripod site that did not get sufficiently archived on the Wayback Machine, so I ended up spending my morning wading around in the archives of an old Yahoo Group, circa 2002. I'd been lurking for a while at that point, but this particular Yahoo Group--XFMU, appropriating Mulder's crack about being the FBI's most unwanted to refer to the X-Files' most unwanted characters, Doggett and Reyes--was the first time I talked, interacted, made friends, wrote stuff. And it's all still there, though I first had to convince Yahoo I wasn't trying to hack my own account, since it had been years and years since I'd signed in.

Those were my first wave fandom days, before LJ, and certainly before this current fannish diaspora where everything is mainstream across a million platforms and no one actually seems to do anything except post shiny pictures. All those arguments about what posts were appropriate to the list versus how OT (off-topic, for those of you who don't remember the lingo) was acceptable. The fights between the advocates of DSR (Doggett/Scully), DRR (Doggett/Reyes), SRR (Scully/Reyes), and so forth, so earnest and yet even at the time so aware that these were just faint echoes of the great shipper/noromo fights of X-Files years past. Spoiler space in posts that involved actually hitting return a couple dozen times, in the days before cut tags. Everyone promoting her own geocities fic site. And my personal favorite, the network of people mailing VHS tapes around the country to people who weren't able to catch the episodes for some reason.

Yet of course by 2002 this phase was already waning. People were moving to LJ, were starting to take advantage of platforms that required less coding skill and produced prettier results, not to mention that blurred the lines between fandoms, personal and fannish lives, and what was and was not OT. The heyday of the lists and the geocities sites were the late 90s, so there's something already nostalgic about those early 2000s lists that figure so prominently in my personal fandom nostalgia.

The fic I was remembering was bad and cliched and yet still great fun to reread after forever. The conversations were as they ever were, and continued to be, up until the point fandom stopped having proper conversations about things. (I gather that some of this sort of happens on Tumblr? Yet also not?) And in the intervening 13 years, fandom has changed a lot, as has the internet, as have I and no doubt all of the other fangirls (and a handful of fanboys) who used to populate those old lists. We used to have a great secret about how much we loved these shows and these characters (even the ones that no one else seemed to love--and perhaps it was the joy of finding those other people who did love Doggett and Reyes, despite all the hate, that made that particular list such a favorite of mine), and part of the great joy was finding these people out there in the world who shared that secret.

And I wonder if, in this current great fervor we have for rebooting old fannish hits--new Star Wars, new X-Files, new Gilmore Girls, new Star Trek--we're trying to recapture something of the way we loved those things, more, perhaps, than trying to recapture the things themselves. My great first fannish love, The X-Files, was as much about the experience of loving it with other people as it was the show itself: the great revelation that other people also felt this way, the shipper wars, the mytharc guesses and analyses, and so forth.

And I will DEFINITELY be watching the new episodes, but is there something lost in the fact that everyone else will be, too? In the fact that there will now be paid critics at highbrow organs of journalism leading the discussion rather than fangirls on a message board or Yahoo group or LJ community? I want to hear the opening music again, to see Mulder and Scully replay the same beloved scenarios, and so forth (Mulder will believe, Scully will be skeptical, Mulder will get depressed and question all he's ever known, Scully will declare she believes in him if not in the paranormal, Skinner will be awesome in the background, the mytharc will make no fucking sense whatsoever, and at some point they'll wave some flashlights around a dark room--if this is not the substance of the reboot, I'm taking my toys and going home). But will it really be the same if it's a major multinational phenomenon acted out specifically because of the nostalgia for something we know we've lost? Of course not. But it won't stop us from hoping, I suspect (and wailing that we knew better if it's terrible).

In the meantime, I'm trying to decide whether the selective XF episode rewatch should extend throughout the whole series. Or is that, too, better left as is.
pellucid: (Ellison praying)
2015, y'all. This has not really been my year. As I look back at the, what, four posts so far this year, I see all my January hopes, my late May broken foot low point (long story: turned out not to be broken after all, and my podiatrist is a moron, but we're way past that in medical tales), and one would hope I would have sprung back from all that, with the bright hopes promised in my new apartment, my new neighbor [personal profile] chaila, my new boss, and so forth. And it is true: the new apartment and neighborhood are fantastic, having a [personal profile] chaila of my very own all the time is the best, and the new boss is wonderful and a dramatic improvement over the last one.

And yet.

It started in August, when this pain in my lower abdomen started to get a little worse and a little more consistent, and I started poking around and made the alarming discovery that there was a palpable thing on the left side of my lower abdomen. A round hardness. A mass. Cue googling and panic, and medical care that took rather longer than my scared impatient self wanted it to, and in the end, I do not have cancer or anything dreadful, but I do have a fibroid the size of a cantaloupe, which I'm having cut out, c-section-style, because that's the only way to remove a cantaloupe, apparently, in 12 days. Desperately looking forward to this, if not to the 6-week recovery.

And so my summer of waiting has turned into a fall of more waiting, with pain, and just a general not-right-ness that is possibly related to Oscar the jerkface fibroid and possibly related to...I don't know. It's always a problem of causality, isn't it. Does depression cause not-right-ness? Does not-right-ness cause depression? Are they both caused by something else, like hormones out of whack or chronic stress or intestinal bacteria or all of the above?

Whatever the cause, I'm not right. I read somewhere that people think of depression as sadness but it's really more the emotional equivalent of watching paint dry. This has been a fall of abdominal pain and watching paint dry. Of junk TV in reruns and the utter failure to engage intellectually in anything. Of a complete lack of focus, in which it's kind of a miracle I've been able to keep up with my job. And I have plans to deal with some of this after the current health crisis is over (deeply curious, for instance, to see whether simply having the surgery helps, or if it's actually going to take a big retooling of the brain drugs and so forth). But much of that is on hold because major surgery in 12 days.

In the meantime, work goes on, and work is asking me to write, as it does from time to time. And...I can't. I really can't. I'm so out of practice, and I stare at the screen and nothing comes, and I have this faint memory of being a person who wrote essays and articles and fic and meta and a goddamned dissertation, and I was good at it, and it's all just gone, and the cursor blinks and the paint dries, slowly.

So the thing I can do, for the next 12 days, in the days after that, once I'm out of the hospital and the painkiller haze and whatever else will happen afterwards, is practice words. Not the work words, at least not here, and not yet--the articles that I keep saying I want to write, to advance my career in the ways I keep saying I want to do, according to some remote part of my brain, divorced from the part of my brain that mostly just wants to watch CSI reruns and play Candy Crush all day--not those words yet, but some words. Hell, even just words about CSI reruns and Candy Crush would be a start. (CSI:NY: still ridiculous, but god, I love Stella Bonasera.)

Words. Habits. Brains doing brain things. Remembering to actually write stuff in this journal now and then. Baby steps.
pellucid: (reading sunshine)
Remember how I was going to write more this year? Ha!

Other of my January intentions went fairly well, though. I wanted to embrace some kind of fun, physical, childlike way of movement. I started dancing in my living room. I talked about parkour and jazz.

And then I went beyond talking and actually signed up for a beginner parkour class. Y'all, so much fun!!!! I was TERRIBLE!! Really, truly terrible, in all the ways you might expect for a short, overweight, 34-year-old trying to do an activity that is all about sprinting and jumping and climbing (without holds!) and so forth. But it was a fun terrible. The environment in the gym was fantastic and encouraging, and I could see myself improving. Most of all, I was doing all this crazy fun stuff that I hadn't done since childhood. Vaulting over boxes! Swinging on monkey bars!

You will note the past tense. The first thing we learned in parkour was how to land on the balls of our feet with loose knees, in order to minimize impact. So for five weeks, I landed a lot on the balls of my feet. On balance beams, curbs, the floor, etc. I didn't notice the first time it hurt. But soon there was a nagging pain in my right toe, in the joint around the ball of my foot. One day I wore shoes with just a bit of a heel, and I thought I was going to die with that weight on the ball of my foot. I figured I'd skip parkour for a couple of days and hope it would get better. It didn't. I decided to go to the doctor, who promptly sent me for an x-ray. By the end of the day I was in a walking boot with a fracture diagnosis (the sesamoid, which is the bone right under the ball of the foot) and strict instructions not to do anything high-impact for a long time. No running, and especially no parkour.

This could be worse, I keep telling myself. [livejournal.com profile] gabolange, of course, has been dealing with a much more severe foot injury (I swear I didn't do this out of BFF sympathy!). When you're injured, people start telling you their own injury stories, and I've heard plenty that were far worse than mine. For now, at least, I'm still walking, albeit slowly and awkwardly. I can take the boot off to sleep and shower. Crutches are a threat but not yet a reality. It's been painful but not nearly as painful as it might have been had I fractured something different. Etc.

All that said, however, it's been a tough month and will continue to be a tough summer, I suspect. I feel very stuck: just as I was starting to figure out how to move in ways I have always wanted to, I'm now not even able to move well at all. Most forms of exercise are difficult or impossible. Doing normal tasks like going to work or to the grocery store are suddenly much more difficult (I don't drive, and a work day that doesn't involve anything other than just going to work and coming home again still involves around 3 miles of walking). I wanted this to be the year I set my body free, and instead I'm more weighed down than ever.

So it's a summer of waiting to heal. There are other waits, too. I've been anxious to move for months, but my lease isn't up until August--so I'm waiting to move. There are some significant and I think very positive changes coming at work--in August. But in the meantime...

In the meantime, I need to enjoy my summer, to make it meaningful (not just to watch lots of TV, which has been the main thing so far). Maybe I'll get back to the plan to write more. Possibly I'll finally finish my very long overdue Galentine's Fic. I will read things and watch things, no doubt. But still--what does one do when the weather is splendid (or hot and swampy, depending on the day and one's pov) but going places involves walking and walking is a giant pain (literal and metaphorical)? When the obvious ways to go out and enjoy one's city involve, as [livejournal.com profile] gabolange calls it, the "museum shuffle," which is the worst thing for foot injuries? When reading and writing and watching are all lovely, but one also needs interaction with other humans, sunshine, fresh air, and movement? When one's favorite season has just been dampened considerably. I have higher hopes for fall, but in the meantime, I need to make something of my summer. Suggestions welcome!
pellucid: (Red Shoes)
Once upon a time, I had a record called "Tina the Ballerina." I was maybe 4 or 5. I LOOOOOOOOVED it. I would dance around the living room, spinning and twirling. I had no more grace then than I do now, and once I twirled so hard that I lost my balance and knocked out my two front teeth on the piano bench (baby teeth, fortunately). That was basically the end of my burgeoning dance career.

I proceeded to go through life reading books and playing music and not dancing. I have never been graceful. When dancing is required at a party, I tend to do the very tame bouncing back and forth kind of dancing: not good, but not embarrassing. Meanwhile, I've always really loved dance. Swing Kids in my teenage years, SYTYCD (on YouTube; I have no patience for all the stuff in between the dancing) as an adult. And I always secretly wish I could do even a little of what they do, but instead I tamely bounce back and forth at parties when required. Too self-conscious. And maybe a little too protective of my two front teeth.

Lately, however, I've started dancing with abandon, alone in my living room. I've tried some YouTube tutorials, and I'm SO BAD. I have learned precisely two dance steps (basic Charleston and basic salsa). So I put on music, practice one of my two steps for a while, and then just twirl and jump and flail around in a way I would never do with anyone watching. It's So. Much. Fun. I dare you: put on "Sing Sing Sing" or something like that, dance around a room by yourself, and fail to smile at the end of it. Can't be done.

**

January has been challenging in terms of a fresh new start, because it's one of our busiest times at work. In light of that, I've been doing okay with the idea of practicing good habits and doing what I intend to do, but I'm not where I'd hoped. But this, I suppose, is the idea behind practice. Not that practice makes perfect, but that practice makes it just a little easier to practice better the next time.

**

I'm actually having ALL SORTS of fannish thoughts right now, but it's all a secret until Galentine's Day, and it's driving me crazy that I can't share. But in a month or so, there will be fic and maybe some meta from me. In case anyone still cares about that sort of thing. :)
pellucid: (reading sunshine)
This is my seventh post of 2014, the previous six all coming before May. Meep! One of my goals for 2015 is to write more. Just more, period, about whatever. Maybe (hopefully) fic, and fannish commentary and so forth, but probably also just a lot of whatever. Feel free to read and comment, or not, if you're still around anyway. But I'm getting rusty at writing, and I have this platform, so hopefully there will be more than seven posts in 2015!

Looking back, though, 2014 was somewhat uneventful for me personally. Less so for other members of my family: I gained a sister-in-law and a nephew, both in September, both completely awesome. But those are really the only big milestones, and given how eventful the past few years have been, that's probably okay. I did good work, I met good friends, I traveled to Kansas City, Kentucky (several times), various parts of California, New Mexico, Delaware, and Minneapolis at various points, both for work and play. California was awesome; Kansas City was not. I read whatever the hell I wanted to, just because, without ever having to teach or write about it, or do anything at all beyond making some semi-coherent book club comments, and it was marvelous. (My favorite book of the year: The Warmth of Other Suns by Isabel Wilkerson.) I got a Kindle and have not yet decided if the lightweight and one-click-book-acquisition convenience of it outweighs the fact that it sort of conflicts with my fairly non-linear reading style, but I suspect I will soon be converted for most types of books.

Overall, 2014 was unobjectionable, but I do think I coasted a bit. I had noble intentions and did not realize a lot of them. I'm going to practice doing better in 2015. I really only have one overarching 2015 resolution: to do the things I intend to do. To write. To exercise. To eat less sugar. To wake up earlier. To meditate. To read more. To connect more with people. To take advantage of this cool city where I live. Not to coast. 2015: Year of Action. It won't be perfect, of course; I know myself too well to pretend that I can suddenly change such a deeply ingrained habit/aspect of personality (I've been a procrastinator forever, for instance). But I think I can practice action, and in practice get a little better. And hopefully the practice means I'll be around here more regularly.
pellucid: (suitcase)
Over the past few months I've been working my way through a full rewatch of The West Wing, concluding in a 2 1/2-day mainline of season 7 when I was home sick this week. My initial watching had not been that methodical. I didn't start at the beginning, but did watch regularly from season 2-ish through season 5-ish when it was airing. Then the end of the show combined with John Spencer's death meant I watched the last quarter or so of season 7 live. At some point I went back and watched seasons 1 and 2 straight through. With the exception of late season 5 through early season 7, I'd seen all of it at some point, and I'd seen some of the eps in that gap, as well.

But my relationship with The West Wing had always been more of it being a pleasant backdrop to my college years. Deeply beloved but not as deeply engrained as some of the other shows I loved at the same time. I was still obsessed with The X-Files and starting to fall for Stargate: SG-1 at the time: those were the shows where I had every episode title memorized. Never this one. So my memories were a little spotty: sharp memories of particular moments or episodes, combined with some gaps, combined with some hazier impressions. My narrative of the show was, I think, the common one: it was great until Sorkin left, and then it kind of jumped the shark, but still managed to end on a strong note.

As a result, it's been really interesting to rewatch--all of it, all in a row, as the person I am now as opposed to the person I was then. I still love this show a lot, for some of the same reasons I did before, but also a lot of different ones, and my show narrative looks a lot different now. For instance:

1. Yes, the show had better writing and tighter storylines and more flash and pizazz in the first four seasons, but wow, did it ever become less misogynistic after Sorkin left! It was really surprising to me just how sexist a lot of those early, memorable, and beloved episodes turned out to be in retrospect. And that whole thread really disappears in the latter three seasons. Also, seasons 5-7 are much better than I had thought/remembered. Sure, the Zoey kidnapping plot was horrible, and there were some boring and unfortunate episodes, like the one where CIA Kate and Drunk Leo hung out with Castro in the 90s, but on the whole, it's still good television.

2. It was also a little surprising to me how conservative it was, in retrospect. I was kind of a baby liberal in college. I grew up in a fairly conservative, religious environment, had a scary raging evangelical phase in high school, and then, thank God, discovered feminism in college. A lot of really basic left-leaning ideas were still pretty fresh and revolutionary to me when this show was on the air, and it felt like it was singing my song. Now, of course, I'm a proper communist, as [livejournal.com profile] gabolange would say, (not precisely, but I am a socialist and a pacifist and a staunch anti-nationalist) and wow, is this show conservative and militaristic. Even in the pre-9/11 years when it thought it was being all leftist and edgy. Oh, America...

3. Ugh, Josh and Donna. Why do you make me care about your horrible selves??? I really don't know why I don't hate them. Josh is such an ass, especially to Donna, and she could do so much better, but instead she just takes it and lets herself be his punching bag, and yet I still find myself cheering for them getting it together in the end, even though he never apologized for his many years of being an ass, or for the particularly horrible things that precipitated their estrangement in season 6. Why do I care??? Why can't I just handwave you away to do your unhealthy codependent, quasi-abusive relationship thing in peace? Instead, I'm all "aww, Josh/Donna! Finally!" Narrative manipulation. I, too, still fall for it.

4. On the other hand, CJ and Toby!!! Not CJ/Toby. I've never shipped them, though I see why people do. But these two are my favorites--originally, now, forever. Toby is my favorite to start, and probably through the whole Sorkin era, with CJ a very close second. He drives me up the wall sometimes with some of his views, but I do love the passion of Toby's convictions. Few people love like Toby loves. And I love Toby and Andy and the twins and the fact that he was always going to go out in a flame of self-destruction because the world just doesn't live up to his ideals. Oh, but CJ wins out in the end, for me but not just me. I think the show as a whole decides CJ is its favorite in the end: so much of the end of season 7 is about CJ's journey, and the road she's traveled, from the brilliant and talented but somewhat green press secretary to chief of staff who owns her authority and wants to work for a living and has learned how to make her own choices. She's the character who grows the most over the course of the show, and as a result, it becomes her show, maybe more than it's Jed Bartlet's show, or anyone else's. I'm still not wild that they gave her a kid in the flash-forward, and I'm ambivalent about CJ/Danny, but overall, I still want to be CJ when I grow up. (Except that I think CJ at the beginning of the show is supposed to be roughly the age I am now, and that's really depressing.)

I could come up with more--about what a phenomenal tribute they made to Leo and John Spencer, about the most excellent way they came to an end, about how I hope that Charlie and Zoey live their separate lives for a while and keep in touch and maybe in 10 years or so end up together after all, or at least stay very dear friends for the rest of their lives. But this has never been a show that I've loved in detail, and I suspect that's not going to change now. Rather, it's the broad sweeps of narrative, and my narrative about the show is different now, but still beloved, and I've found it well worth the time to have rewatched it this way.

Profile

pellucid: (Default)
pellucid

January 2025

S M T W T F S
   1234
56 7891011
12131415161718
19202122232425
262728293031 

Syndicate

RSS Atom

Most Popular Tags

Style Credit

Expand Cut Tags

No cut tags
Page generated Jul. 18th, 2026 12:08 pm
Powered by Dreamwidth Studios