Grab a frozen hot chocolate – Christmas is coming early with another Buffalo-made holiday movie premiere.
“The Trouble with Christmas Mistletoe,” which filmed here in March, debuts July 9 on Pure Flix streaming and at 8 p.m. July 11 on the Great American Family channel and the GFam+ app as part of the “Great American Christmas in July” programming.
Set in the fictional small town of Brookhollow, N.J., the movie utilizes locations in South Buffalo, East Aurora, Niagara Falls and Wilson. It’s the second film here for actress Jillian Murray who was in Buffalo last year making Mario Lopez Presents: “Chasing Christmas” which premiered in December 2025 on Great American.
Murray plays an acquisitions executive at a New York City development firm who returns home at the holidays to buy the old Brookhollow Community Center. Her plans stall when she discovers it is now owned by her former fiancé, Luke (Brett Varvel of “County Rescue”) who has no interest in selling. The 70-year-old community center has seen better days, but it’s been an important part of the community for decades and Luke considered it his second home growing up.
Seeking community support, Victoria visits the home of Mrs. Kingston, her former teacher and the mayor’s mother. But it’s Luke who opens the door as the new owner of the historic Kingston House. (He’s been busy.) Both the community center and Kingston House have special memories for Luke and Victoria which played into his decision to buy them. “This was the last place we were in love,” the sensitive Luke finally tells Victoria about the community center.
But Victoria fights her emotions. She repeatedly calls the community center “rundown” and coldly tells Luke that “the last thing I’m interested in is buying an old Victorian home in a small town.” Ouch.
Yes, it has the familiar plot of a person sent from their big-city job back to their small hometown to facilitate a business move that involves a beloved community landmark. And there is the person they left behind who wants to preserve it. (The script references this conflict when a disheartened Luke talks about Victoria’s big-city ambition vs. his small-town reliability.) One of them will have to make a sacrifice if they want both love and a career.

Not with this film, however, and I appreciate it. Neither Victoria nor Nick must give up on their dreams even though they are both willing. And there isn’t a nefarious corporation stirring up trouble. In fact, it is Victoria’s boss who reminds her she has options. It feels more honest this way.
To work through their differences and emotions, they will need help from their believable support system including Victoria’s mother, played by Buffalo native Josie DiVincenzo (“Friends,” “Daredevil”) and Luke’s best friend, Jim (Anthony Carvello).
“The Trouble with Christmas Mistletoe” is one of 13 films made locally by Great American over the past year. It is the 10th to premiere via Great American Media platforms. All but two of the 13 films are holiday themed.
Great American recently wrapped production on “Christmas at the Starlight” starring Mario Lopez and Tony Danza. It is expected to premiere Thanksgiving weekend.
BUFFALO LOCATIONS
Some of the locations used in this film will be familiar to holiday TV viewers (like Vidler’s), but there are other spots that are getting their first time in the spotlight. Here’s a look at the main locations.
The Knights of Columbus Monsignor Nash Council 3875 in South Buffalo stands in for the community center. The brick exterior and several spaces inside are used for multiple scenes.
The Hyde Park Pavilion in Niagara Falls is the ice rink at the community center.
Yeoman’s House in East Aurora is the Kingston House. Its grand exterior is impressive on screen. Built in 1885, the High Victorian Queen Anne home with a 75-foot-tall tower, was added to the National Register of Historic Places in 2024.
Erway’s Christmas Tree Adventure in Wilson basically plays itself in several scenes for holiday events.
East Aurora, which has been integral in multiple locally made holiday movies, again plays a role. One of the first images is Vidler’s familiar red and white awning, with a close-up of the clock and street thermometer that was registering near zero. Characters walk and talk along Main Street and use one of quaint stairways between stores that connects Main Street to the back parking lots.
Great Point Buffalo film studio on Niagara Street, a partner of Great American Media, serves as the New York City offices of Clark and Johnson, Victoria’s employer.
NOTES
“The Trouble with Christmas Mistletoe” is the new title of this film, which until very recently was called “The Trouble with Mistletoe.” Slight difference, but significant because there was a 2017 movie of the same name. Online searches will call up both movies (and use the wrong photos), so look at the year the film was made for clarification.
Local behind-the-scenes crew include cinematographer Matthew Quinn, costume designer Erin Meegan, camera operator Mandy Hebblethwaite, casting director Frank Rossi and casting associate Josh Nuncio.
MORE TO READ, WATCH
Read about two other recent premieres of Buffalo-made movies from Great American.
Blessings in Disguise is next Buffalo-made movie to premiere on TV, streaming
Buffalo-made ‘Meet Me in the Margins’ is a charming bookish romance
















