Endurance in the Cancer House

What are the roots that clutch, what branches grow
Out of this stony rubbish? Son of man,
You cannot say, or guess, for you know only
A heap of broken images, where the sun beats,
And the dead tree gives no shelter, the cricket no relief,
And the dry stone no sound of water. Only
There is shadow under this red rock,
(Come in under the shadow of this red rock),
And I will show you something different from either
Your shadow at morning striding behind you
Or your shadow at evening rising to meet you;
I will show you fear in a handful of dust.

– T. S. Eliot, The Waste Land

… there is a kind of chronic-time disaster taking place […] – a disaster or fixation-entrapment in which human beings are being pushed further and further away from lucidity, and therefore from a focus state of love and exploration.

– Justin Barton, Hidden Valleys: Haunted by the Future

… the idea of a return from death fractures all traditional conceptions of temporality. The temporality to which the ghost is subject is therefore paradoxical, as at once they ‘return’ and make their apparitional debut.

– Peter Buse and Andrew Stott, Ghosts: Deconstruction, Psychoanalysis, History

Image
Image
Image

Hyper / Slow

After the purgatorial years of the COVID pandemic, sonic temporalities have been re-stretched in two dynamic directions. On the one hand, the online ‘hyperpop’ revival, instigated via the emergence of ‘dariacore’, has taken EDM to new extremes, where a semioblitz approach to sampling tears recent cultural histories into evermore jagged pieces through the unprecedented g-force of Gen Z’s initiation into creative maturity. On the other, a slowcore revival (often credited to the so-called ‘Duster Effect’) liquifies post-pandemic rock into a new molasses.

Both of these currents attach themselves to long-since-lost continua, equally rejecting the ‘frenzied stasis’ of the present. Here we have sonic accelerationisms and hauntologies reanimated, whether through the electrified probes of so many Frankensteinian surgeons after the death of rave or the slow decay of microbial forces eating at the debris left behind in the Long Nineties’ wake. As two mutant resuscitations of pre-Y2K antagonisms, then, we bear witness to a new generation that rejects any and all illusions of ‘stable temporalities’, just as their forebears did:

History insists upon a linear causal progression – a neat passage from the past (which is already decided) to the future (which is merely the playing out of what has been laid down in the past). […] Beyond this causality is another temporality […]. Here, cause does not follow effect: there is a process of retrocontamination in which the deep past finds itself already infected with the far future. The crucial question is one of becoming: what are you changing into, what is growing out of you?

On both sides, Nineties sensibilities return, albeit not always recognisably. This is more true of hyperpop’s second wave, it must be said, whereas the slowcore revival continues to remain loyal to the late-twentieth-century atmospheres curated by Chicago label Kranky and the likes of Low or Godspeed You! Black Emperor. But given this sound’s inherently revenant nature, few would expect the flatline of the slowcore continuum to generate anything wholly new.

What matters is the renewed appreciation for these sensibilities, as the spluttering hyperdrive of the mid-2020s triggers a new need for counter-temporalities that carves out empty spaces for the work of mourning to unfold apart from the automated speed-traps of contemporary life.

As hyperpop jitters in its irradiated unlife of ever-circulating particle-chaos, slowcore staggers out from the tomb to return from the dead. Time has once again been rendered seductively out of joint.

Flowers Over There

Londoners seeking out slowness have been spoilt recently. After Grouper’s sold-out two-night residency at Café OTO this week – for which I failed to get any tickets – the apparitional London debut of Chicago’s newest slowcore collective, Cancer House, at Longfield Hall in Myatt’s Fields is the next best thing.

It was not a part of London I had been to before. Enquiring whether any friends were up for coming along, there was always the jarring recognition that the band’s evocative name hardly announces their scheduled performance as a good time. Even sonically, Cancer House bring to mind the dusty corridors of a purgatorial hospice where the terminally ill wait out their demise. In the end, I took my broken heart alone.

The night itself was a complex affair. Rosemary Moss began with a beautiful short set of songs, played gently on a piano sat resting in front of an alcove stage, on top of which her band added cobwebbed ornamentations to her haunting folk vocal.

Shelter & Orion swerved drastically elsewhere, occupying the middle of the hall where they took downbeat from belt to bunker with a tape deck and a long, dark tunnel. As I swayed in place for what felt like the longest set of the night, the crowd around them was more uncertain, bounding back and forth between the music hall and the ‘smoking area’ (or front porch). For those who stayed for the duration, we were dragged on a post-TG urbex excursion across an abandoned factory floor as acid rain dubbed through to inner space via bass that shook the building’s foundations. It was excellent.

Cancer House’s staggering presence both confirmed and challenged their existence as denizens of ‘shy-town’, playing in the deep shadow of the recessed stage with the lights down. Their sound filled the room with heat, whereas I had expected them to feel colder. Still, the Blues turned monochrome here, going through not so much an update as a downdate, passing an empty time after the end of a world. One verse shrieked in the entire set felt like a catharsis that stunned the neighbourhood.

Image
Image
Image

Endurance

I loved the show, but left not knowing what to think or what to feel. Four hours passed quickly, but I left self-conscious at having been there alone. I went to feel something, but it was just another Friday night out for all the couples and groups of friends drinking overpriced bottles of beer in attendance. There were also the usual hipsters who talked through most of it, probably showing up just to say they were there. I went to have something ripped out of me – another kind of gig-going cliché – but the thorn still lingered on the frosted walk home.

The next day, I barely got out of bed. Everyone is complaining about their lack of energy this week. Winter has flooded in and it seems like no one has been physically prepared for it. It is adding weight to a depression already being weathered, which Cancer House briefly exorcised, but all too temporarily. The night encapsulated something, but it did not alleviate it. I don’t know why I expected it to.

I no longer feel like I am going out of my way looking for answers or solutions to all of life’s problems. There are too many. Then, in my inbox, a new post from Erik Davis brings as much unexpected solace as Cancer House’s inscrutable sound did. Not clarity, so much as acceptance.

“One of the great struggles that jangle our mental ecology these days is the contradiction between, on the one hand, the extensive power and performance of knowing, and, on the other, a profound confusion and uncertainty about what the actual fuck is going on”, Davis begins. He offers some insightful commentary on how this jangling of our mental is playing out today, in the age of all-knowing AI and the cultural capital dished out to the knowledgeable, which is well worth a read, but it was a later acknowledgement that resonated most with my own sensibilities this winter:

The existential risks of our moment […] have bred a return of existential questions, which are precisely those questions that we cannot answer but must endure…

I hate not knowing. I hate it more than anything. It is what I have hated most this past year. I hate not knowing what the future holds, nor what the consequences of my responses to the here and now will ultimately be. The benefit of hyperpop and slowcore, perhaps, as subcultures equally fugitive from capture in their unconventional time-signatures, is that I do not always know what I am hearing, but now not-knowing is given over to sublimity. It is harder to find that serenity in daily life, so I take solace in their not-knowing for that.

Davis, in conclusion, quotes from M. John Harrison’s The End of Everything – a book I recently picked up and have been trying to find the energy to read. Now I feel like I must pick it up in earnest:

We’re suspended in this new catastrophe. We’re held in suspension. It’s ongoing and unresolved. It never ends. The nature of the catastrophe is that it has no nature.

This passage is – again, unexpectedly – the perfect summation of the Cancer House show too. When it ended, it felt like it had barely begun. I continued to listen to their latest record on repeat for the journey home. As a soundtrack to our catastrophe, it is at once blistering new and achingly familiar. Theirs is a sound that is helping me to endure the present’s irresolvability.

Sometimes, there’s nothing more you can say, want, or hope for than that.

It is 03.30 in the morning…

It is 03.30 in the morning. Let us say one is ‘drunk’ – an impoverished cypher for all those terrible things one does to one’s nervous-system in the depths of the night – and philosophy is ‘impossible’ (although one still thinks, even to the point of terror and disgust). What does it mean for this episode in the real history of spirit to die without a trace? Where has it strayed to? […]

An extraordinary lucidity, frosty and crisp in the blackness, but paralysed; lodged in some recess of the universe that clutches it like a snare. A wave of nausea is accompanied by a peculiarly insinuating headache, as if thought itself were copulating unreservedly with suffering. A damp coldness, close to fog, creeps through the open window. I laugh, delighted at the fate that has turned me into a reptile. The metallic hardness of intellect seems like a cutting instrument in my head; the detached fragment from a machine tool, or an abattoir, seeking out the terminal sense it was always refused.

It must be a decade since I first read the melodramatic opening to Nick Land’s book on Bataille, The Thirst for Annihilation. Its prose does not entice like it once did, but as I rise from my bed at 2.45am to sit at my laptop and try to lure sleep to call upon me, I can’t help but think of that refrain, which used to make me laugh so much back then, like one of his more contemporary Boomer tweets.

It is 03.30 in the morning. Let us say one is ‘drunk’…

Land’s debut is wilfully unruly, much like what was still to come. It renders the experience of philosophy itself – or philosophizing – as a horror story. I’m sure that perspective is already familiar to many (although perhaps not many readers here)… Land’s intention, nonetheless, is to jibe with the insinuation that philosophy is only produced by analytic persons of “undisturbed reasoning”, as if philosophy were only valid as a product of clarity and understanding, and less so when draped in the garb of someone actively wrestling with what passes for reality in the dead of night.

This wrestling is something I obviously still engage with, and it still tends to happen at 03.30 in the morning as well. But these days, one is never ‘drunk’. And yet, what of those other intoxications? Those things that the nervous system does to itself unwarranted when ‘reasonable’ people are asleep?

I was sick for two days last week and it finally put a stop to my manic wanderings across central London – not entirely, but I did spend a full day in bed on Wednesday (the first full day of total immobility since I moved here two months ago; today has been the second). Inner experience has been erratic the past two months to say the least, and what has returned with the darker days of winter is an insomnia that I’d hoped to have moved beyond. It takes me so long to fall asleep, and then, apropos of nothing, I wake up at 8am regardless, incapable of lying in.

To struggle to fall asleep and then stay asleep is torturous. The growing bags under my eyes let me know that I cannot get away with keeping this condition under wraps. It warps my face in new ways each morning and I feel like I am watching myself age rapidly. For that reason, it invokes a weird nostalgia, as I trace the shadowy crow’s feet pattered out by so many memories of insomnias past. I know the cause, and the world reminds of it. My Instagram algorithm – try as I might to avoid the coupling, bedrotting and doomscrolling are the perfect pair – has also taken to showing me info-reels about Complex PTSD, which I’ve barely thought about for three years but have previously been treated for. The insomnia alerts me to its continuing presence, no doubt reawakened after the past year of additional traumas, and images of the family home are never far away.

The last time I could not sleep – not counting my recent move to London itself, during which I found myself awake for days at a time over the course of two weeks – was three years ago, not long after the release of Oneohtrix Point Never Again. I wrote about my Dad back then. Before that, there have been many other episodes, but the one that comes to mind repeatedly is a period in 2014 when I was still living in Hull. I would lie in bed, staring at the ceiling, and then sneak out of the house before anyone else was awake to spend the day driving aimlessly around East Yorkshire. In the early hours, I would not have to explain myself. I would not have to fight my way to the front door. One morning, I stopped off at the local supermarket to buy petrol and cigarettes and the cashier, who I did not know, commented curtly: “Fuck, dude, you look tired.” And I was. I have never forgotten that moment. The embarrassment seared it into memory. Soon afterwards, I no doubt took myself down to Little Switzerland – a small area beneath the Humber Bridge, known as a good spot for Sunday afternoon walks and nighttime dogging. I’d sit in the car ‘inherited’ from my mum in the midst of her agoraphobic psychosis, chain-smoking and reading Heidegger’s Being & Time, listening to Lee Gamble or the sound of the River Humber lapping at the banks of the foreshore, sitting in the sense that everything was gradually being eroded.

Insomnia is awful for the ways in which it compounds a sense of stasis. There is an energy – a nervous energy from nowhere. It has no reason for being there, and yet it is there. I am alert. I would love not to be. So I sit in it. If it weren’t raining, I might try and walk it off, giving myself the illusion of some ‘plot development’, but not tonight. I turn to the piles of books growing like cairns out of my bedroom floor, but I end up barely touching them. Instead, waiting for the mind to tire itself out on old memories and emotions that shouldn’t live here anymore but still occasionally come knocking, I try writing. At this time of night, philosophy is ‘impossible’, but it also feels alive. Or rather, nighttime is the time of thought’s potent unlife. It emerges in monstrous forms. Thought occurs unfiltered. Something aches to be conceptualised. Some image of reality cries to be dissected. But thought also has no real will to clarify itself or even express itself. It simply happens, like a tremor, and the midnight dust finds somewhere to settle down as my hands glide back and forth without due attention across my keyboard.


As the year drags to a glacial close, I find myself deep in the k-punk archive once again, wandering through Mark Fisher’s particularly productive 2004, when he too seemed to be writing himself out of a deep, dark funk. His ‘end-of-year round up’ refers to a period of mental ill-health that has not been dwelled upon on the blog up until this point. Nor is it dwelled upon here for long. Instead, he celebrates his favourite pop-cultural moments of the last twelve months and the new community of bloggers he has found himself immersed within. It has a similar tenor to Land’s ‘3.30am’ confessional, but veers towards joy:

Best of times, worst of times, all that.

Perhaps mercifully, I can’t remember much from the start of ’04 – intermittent continuity gaps being one of the consequences of periodic mental debilitation – but I like to think that my recovery is more than a personal matter (and only partly because there is nothing personal).

When I started k-punk, things couldn’t have seemed more hopeless. The APE [Alien Parasite Entity] was running the show, no amount of encouragement from the likes of Luke and Matt could convince me that what I was typing wasn’t abject… And yet, the writing continued… I must go on, I can’t go on, I’ll go on… Proof that writing, far from being about self-expression, emerges in spite of the subject.

The role of the Net-based collective machine in getting me out of Hell cannot be underestimated.

It can’t only have had that effect on me.

I wish this space was as populous as it once was. No one blogs anymore. Many of those who have tacked onto those energies after the fact have done well to professionalize them. (No shade – I wish I was more adept at making money off these energies sometimes, but alas, I am fuelled by different impulses and have never learned the formalities of a more marketable presentation…) Those who shared my lack of interest in professionalization have either taken up an interest or since given up the ghost of late-2010s Ccru impersonations. (It is peculiar to see new tributes appear online this year all the same, which seem far more embedded in academic departments than the Ccru themselves ever were.) As a result, I feel more like I am sending these missives out into the void than ever before. It was a different time ten years ago when I had an awareness that people actually read them. How thrilling to overhear your manic ramblings, which were thrown together on your commute to your shitty job, get talked about at gallery openings and house parties by people who had no idea you walked among them. But not anymore. Philosophizing continues but takes place in isolation; thinking in general still happens in community, but not as it once used to.

I mention this only because I think often about how our collective productivities were a product of many of us going through stuff. We were buoyed by our shared obsessions and private precarities. I wonder what everyone is up to these days, now that we no longer shitpost through our angst on Twitter, nor burrow collectively down manic rabbit holes on Slack and Discord servers, nor cross-post our late-night instabilities through inter-blog dialogues. Everyone’s lives must be so different. Mine is too. But still, I find myself up at 3.26am, as it is now, no less enraptured by that feeling of being lost and the enduring naivety that putting some words in a satisfying order might illuminate the path forward, if only for a moment.

Is it really just me that still feels this way? I’m sure it is not, but all others seem ensnared by platform-capture or the monotony of contemporary life where breaking-down / breaking-through online is no longer a viable hobby, or at least it has become one reserved for live-streamers in Big (Br)Other experiments of another order that are more easily monetized. Is nothing sacred? The Lovecraftian archetype of a mad scientist leaving a trail of documentation tracking frowned-upon experiments in journals and on VHS tape has lost all of its romance in the 2020s YouTube era. I’m imagining a ten-part series of Jeff Goldblum transforming himself into a fly interrupted by AI Temu ads every five minutes… I don’t think Mark himself ever expected videodrome to be this boring.

In another post from 2004, Mark quotes another Mark he was very fond of, as he often did: Mark Downham:

The Videodrome has its roots in the stimulus-addictive spectacular commodity-culture and it is realised and reified through the commodity in fashion, style, newness. The spectacular videodrome generates subliminal overstimulation and this hype leads to a craving for more stimulus for its own sake. The Videodrome through the television screen, in words, sound, vision, visual imagery; releases spores, pheromones which make us gorge ourselves on it, always wanting more, whether it’s tactile, sexual, phenomenal, social, material or emotional – seeking what we can never find, the realization of our desires. The video-spectacular pulse inserts a permanent feeling of dissatisfaction of the senses, identity, personality, it collapses each new construct it proffers, it collapses new people. This is an ever-accelerating law of diminishing returns — craving, production, consumption, simulation, excitation, stimulation, craving — the videodrome spectacular hype is never over.

It seems like it is over now… At least in a form that actually felt energizing rather than inoculating of thought. Maybe it never was.

Mark in 2007:

All culture in the 21st century tends to the condition of advertising. More than ever, we live inside adverts and adverts are inside us. The environments we move through are walk-through, interpassive simulations, and we are the carriers of a pulsing videodrome signal that has colonized our unconscious, secreting its banal aspirations into our electric dreams. Specific adverts sell products, but the form of advertising sells Capital itself. Nothing else is on offer.

The desire for a kind of collective breakdown / break-through really becomes a desire for a new health. What attraction is there in writing or philosophizing in a manner that this world deems ‘sane’? Better to wrestle with the re-cracking of a C-PTSD chrysalis and show my working, on the off-chance there are others traipsing down parallel paths preparing to stay punk in a world to come. ‘Punk’, that is, in the sense that Mark used it:

as a distributive cultural tendency facilitated by new technologies. In the same way, ‘punk’ doesn’t designate a particular musical genre, but a confluence outside legitimate(d) space: fanzines were more significant than the music in that they allowed and produced a whole other mode of contagious activity which destroyed the need for centralized control.

Where are those spaces now? Not in prison cells or on Zoom calls. Probably not on blogs either.

But what does it matter… The other problem with writing at 3.28am is that the only path to reveal itself is the one that leads to bed, but maybe that’s where I should be right now.

Radio to the Trash Deity:
Notes on the Exegesis of Philip K. Dick

Cognitive estrangement; that is the key. And the rectification thereof. This is the goal; this is the mystery.

Philip K. Dick saw God everywhere. Not as a higher power, nor a lower power, but an immanent power. His existence was only a neuron-flash in the great Mind of all matter.

Thought is the Great Mind thinking itself across infinite instances. And yet, intuited only as a part of a whole, self-awareness for humanity becomes all the more fleeting and hard-won. Our estrangement from the universe is the default. To come to know it with new intimacy is only to know ourselves better as a part to the whole. But for that same reason, there is nothing more elusive to consciousness than consciousness itself:

cognitive estrangement exists until rectified, and that the person is dependent on an outside source to rouse him to awareness of his state and to reverse that state. Upon it being reversed – ontological ignorance transformed into ontological knowledge – that person’s status in the cosmos, his existential basis within the cosmos as part to whole, is drastically and radically reversed, transforming not only his perception of the world-order and his ability to function in it, but also his perception of his own self.

But how? How does a neuron come to think of itself as part of a thinking thing, only to reinsert itself with new wisdom into the whole of wisdom?

Sculpture, as a monist practice manipulative of the matters of mind, intuits the process. More so than painting or drawing, as the production of flat, static images, sculpture, which is innately hodological, illuminates the mind’s pathways to itself. A block of stone is manipulated in such a way that it becomes something other than what it was. Duchamp’s fountain, impelling a change in perspective, becomes a ‘living’ diagram of matter. Turn the object over in your mind and see what it was then and what it is now and what it is at all times all at once. The pathways inscribe themselves on the air and within the mind. We are ‘moved’ when we join in the movement of matter from mud to porcelain to bathroom to gallery to future rubble.

The final pages of VALIS render Dick’s cosmogony hodological as well, revealing God in the collisions of atoms of dust and debris: “the symbols of the divine show up in our world initially at the trash stratum.” Divinity is the beer can in the gutter run over by a taxi. Divinity is the transformation of matter into new forms at the whim of all energies. This porosity makes all change. ‘God is change’, as it was for Octavia Butler. But which change? “All we know is that things happen.” Surfing metastability, entropy and negentropy buffet person-particles across the great chaosmos.

What buffets us? Who? God is the inhuman will of all matter to be differential. “Each living thing feels impelled to move (to develop or change or grow) but can’t locate the source of that urge.” God is the pure morphology of information and flux-code. “The superimposition of the Logos-Plan pattern causes all material reality, this entire space-time universe, to experience a certain stress to be other than it is, a certain urging to become.” God is incremental transformation and its duration; we are closest to God when we glimpse our capacity to endure durations.

This requires the slowing of time. Transform the instant like putty. Time-stretch your endurances. Imagine neural pathways followed like a dark alley illuminated by lamp light. Step by step, see yourself walking at dusk, at that precise moment when shadows pass over electronic sensors nestled in trees under a coming night sky. Darkness triggers light, as if the world were operating just for you. Electricity flows through unseen networks within you and without. See it all as one. See the event during which the urinal become a fountain. See trash transformed into beauty. Understand the significance stirred by the ego as only an affinity with universe-immersion. Meaning is an orgasm of the mind. Love is sensory immanence as the world envelops and passes through the skin. Joy is the strafing of pathways, of one map laid neatly over another, of matter inter-coursing over concrete and neurology simultaneously.

“All I can think of is that reality is pure consciousness”, Dick writes:

There is a single interacting field and there is a mind ubiquitous in it, immanent in it … Spinoza would agree; in no way do I see God as transcendent to reality, off somewhere far above us in heaven, with Earth down there … deity in the very trash of the alley. And deity intimately connected with and utilising – if not actually being – information.

Attuned to the universe, the radio static blares loud, ready to receive any and all signalling. Strain your ears to hear the blips of radiation, filtered into new forms of radio-action. “Reality was amended by amending the instructions fed it. So it was not amended directly; its received signal was overridden.”

Interesting Feelings

According to Spinoza, to be free is to act according to reason. To act according to reason is to act according to your own interests.

– Mark Fisher, “Spinoza, k-punk, neuropunk”

But as you pursue freedom, so your interests change – perhaps Kantian Duty is only ever useful as a kickstart to this K+ process, i.e. guilt might make one stop watching TV and eating Monster Munch for a day, during which new, positive vectors of desire might install themselves spontaneously – you go for a walk, you watch some lapwings, see some spiders, spill some mushy peas in your pocket – and since you are the sum of your interests (the things you are engaged in, in the milieu of), how can this be anything other than a becoming-non-self (or in k-p terminology becoming-unself, becoming a real fiction of self rather than a fictional real)?

This needs to be clarified in the D/G sense of ‘becoming’ [which] is neither a transformation of an existing substrate-entity (‘self-improvement’ or the capitalisation of the self) or one thing changing into another entity (‘becoming a new person’ or the resentful repudiation of one’s contingency and history) but a substantive ‘becoming-in-it(non)self’, which has neither external origin or goal, a metastable process with a nametag.

[…] That blogging can facilitate this flight whilst at the same time providing multiple snares and traps is no argument against it, of course – that’s the abstract libidinal landscape of life, the thing to do is to learn how the attractors, the black holes and the plateaus work; then you will no longer (a) subject to them…

– Maya B. Kronic [Undercurrent],
“Freedom and Speedfreaks: The Spinoza Discussion”

If I had a reason…

This brief exchange from the k-punk blog has been occupying my thoughts these past few days. Back in the Mark-hive, further elucidating the piecemeal, kollektivized project of ‘psychedelic reason’ has become the new fixation. Its meta-reflexivity is jarring. If “you are the sum of your interests”, and this is a procedure of non-self-(de)cultivation, what becomes of reasoning with the nametag attached to this metastable process at any given moment? Writing – transitioning – ‘figuring things out’ – this is a process of learning “how the attractors, the black holes and the plateaus work”, in the conscious hope of “no longer [being] (a) subject to them…”

Whatever is of interest at the moment – which is certainly taking walks and blogging, amongst far more explicitly collective struggles – is wrestled with for its paradoxes. These things are of interest precisely because there is hope of a day to come in which they will not be of interest any longer. To fixate on them is to risk fully identifying with emotional turmoil, when the less certain outcome longed for is that the rise in intensity will serve a processual reasoning-with the various thorns left in one’s side.

This is the “whole paradox” of Spinozism for Fisher: the aim of an emotional engineering is the tacit understanding of or processual reasoning with “your ultimate interests being to have no interests whatsoever, which is intellectual love of God.” Yes, it travels in two directions – involution and evolution are trajectories along the “cartographic study of the interior of the subject in passive modes / moods plus machinic manual for contact with the outside.”

Fisher quotes Susan Sontag’s Against Interpretation on the counter-intuitive task at hand:

Ours is a culture based on excess, on overproduction: the result is a steady loss of sharpness in our sensory experience. All the conditions of modern material life – its material plenitude, its sheer crowdedness – conjoin to dull our sensory faculties. And it is in the light of the condition of our senses, our capacities (rather than those of another age), that the task of the critic must be assessed.

What is important now is to recover our senses. We must learn to see more, to hear more, to feel more.

The dulling of our senses may be the outcome we want more. There is too much to feel, too much overwhelm, too much to process. But this overexposure dulls our senses for us. Dullness is the purpose of the system – the overproduction of what Woolf called the “cotton wool”. Fisher frames this “once more with feeling” as an anti-capitalist program of abstract engineering explicitly: “Developing more feeling precisely entails being reliant on less external stimuli. Kapital = progressively less from more. Anti-kapital = more from less.”

To feel more, to reflect more, becomes a program of decoding the subject. Why are my present interests so interesting? Where have they come from? I follow an impulse, but nothing feels consciously chosen. A pressure builds over here and over there and I begin opening and closing valves to alleviate pressure. I do not know what is contained in the overflowing reservoir of the emotional self, even as I feel its weight. At times, the release is too much, it is unthinking, it is mess. Nevertheless, it is an enjoyable release (for me) of sad passions. Thus converted into happy passions, these passions are then converted into positive actions.

It is a demonstration of some kind. It is a demonstration of this body’s capacity for movement, discipline, thought, reasoning. It is a demonstration valuable only to one’s self. It becomes a ground of some truth, as if producing proofs of potentiality. ‘What is possible? Well, I did this before, and look, here’s what I am doing now…’ The production of situations to be responded to and navigated through becomes a form of reality-testing, a way of producing concepts and sense that becomes memory for any future self. As Spinoza writes in the Ethics: “the mind is no less sensible of those things which it conceives through intelligence than of those which it remembers, for demonstrations are the eyes of the mind by which it sees and observes things.”

One k-punk commenter (rightly) sees this Spinozan ethics as the entire purpose of the blogging endeavour: “My understanding of the k-punk adventure is this: experiences are had; reports are filed; connections are drawn; observations are made; theories are extracted; proposals are devised; lather; rinse; repeat.” It is an exercise of reason; it is also emotional.

“Human OS systematically confuses ‘reason’ with a literally academic detachment (i.e. non-pragmatic orientation)”, Fisher writes. “Yet, as Nietzsche was so insistent, such ‘reason’ has its own bio-psychic bases and biases (‘no-one is less impersonal than a philosopher’).” He adds later:

Spinoza had got out by positing Reason as something to be attained – a non-human, abstract-material map for escaping identity and achieving flatline communion with uttunul. The analytics are both too slow and too fast – too slow because they have not yet decoded their own immersion in monkeymatic Human OS; too fast because they assume that you can just leap out to reason without undertaking such decoding. Spinoza says you can’t. Start in the middle. The process of reason just is about correlating yr feelings with yr interests. (On Human OS defaults, they are not). So reason = emotional engineering.

There is a rub here. I have feelings, I have interests, I am interested in my feelings, I have feelings about my interests. How do these two things become correlated? The k-punk commenters soon turn to an all-too-familiar, even cliché, but nonetheless provocative demonstration of the point at hand:

Intuition is not the same as emotional intelligence and self-love.

Go on, say it now. As an experiment. Out loud. “I love myself.”

Strange and difficult isn’t it? You might feel embarrassed, absurd, childish. Worse, you might feel NOTHING. NOTHING AT ALL. Feeling, a-voided.

That’s Kapital and patriarchy for you.

You don’t resolve the ‘feeling vs. thinking’ conflict with JUST more thinking. The solution is rational but not intellectual, uses the brain but engages the heart. And in my view, requires “spirit” (though not a particular immaterialist belief system).

Another commenter threads the needle: “I have a suspicion that what you are calling self-love is what Mark is referring to as the production of joyful encounters.” Another adds: “Love is a dog sent from hell.” As ever, Mark himself thinks it would be “better to have another word that isn’t so tainted by horrible associations (think of Burroughs on ‘love love love in buckets of slop’ (paraphrase) in The Ticket That Exploded…).”

What is a Spinozan love? Is it ‘joy’? As it was for Deleuze:

… joy is everything that consists in satisfying a capacity. You experience joy when you satisfy, when you effectuate one of your capacities. What is that? Let’s return to our examples: I conquer, however slightly, a small piece of color, I enter a little into color.

[…] Conversely, what is sadness? It’s when I am separated from a capacity of which I believed myself, rightly or wrongly, capable: Ah, I could have done that, but circumstances prevented it, or it was forbidden, etc. That’s sadness, one should say: all sadness is the effect of a power over me.

To feel incapacitated is to turn, reasonably, to other capacities that one knows one can rely on. Blogging and walking are two. Blogging and walking are prized because they cost nothing. They have no benefit in and of themselves but the satisfaction of a capacity. They are the scratching of an itch to feel alive, which may not satisfy the impulse as one initially thinks of it. It is to poke the ‘spirit’, perhaps, and when the hand inevitably passes straight through the spectre, a choice is made to just keep going outwards on the trajectory of a blind lunge at the matter of self, at what matters to the self. “Brain, heart, hands, feet, pencils, back of envelope, pebbles, paintings, trees, the streets of a city… So many things to think with.”

The Guilt of Non-Being

Often when I have been writing one of my so-called novels I have been baffled by this same problem; that is, how to describe what I call in my private shorthand – “non-being.” Every day includes much more non-being than being. […] A great part of every day is not lived consciously. One walks, eats, sees things, deals with what has to be done […] When it is a bad day the proportion of non-being is much larger.

[…] As a child […], my days, just as they do now, contained a large proportion of this cotton wool, this non-being. […] Then, for no reason that I know about, there was a sudden violent shock; something happened so violently that I have remembered it all my life.

[…] [M]any of these exceptional moments brought with them a peculiar horror and a physical collapse; they seemed dominant; myself passive. This suggests that as one gets older one has a greater power through reason to provide an explanation; and that this explanation blunts the sledgehammer force of the blow. I think this is true, because though I still have the peculiarity that I receive these sudden shocks, they are now always welcome; after the first surprise, I always feel instantly that they are particularly valuable. And so I go on to suppose that the shock-receiving capacity is what makes me a writer. I hazard the explanation that a shock is at once in my case followed by the desire to explain it. I feel that I have had a blow; but it is not […] simply a blow from an enemy hidden behind the cotton wool of daily life; it is or will become a revelation of some order; it is a token of some real thing behind appearances; and I make it real by putting it into words. It is only by putting it into words that I make it whole; this wholeness means that it has lost its power to hurt me; it gives me, perhaps because by doing so I take away the pain, a great delight to put the severed parts together. Perhaps this is the strongest pleasure known to me. It is the rapture I get when in writing I seem to be discovering what belongs to what; making a scene come right; making a character come together. From this I reach what I might call a philosophy; at any rate it is a constant idea of mine; that behind the cotton wool is hidden a pattern; that we – I mean all human beings – are connected with this; that the whole world is a work of art; that we are parts of the work of art. Hamlet or a Beethoven quartet is the truth about this vast mass that we call the world. But there is no Shakespeare, there is no Beethoven; certainly and emphatically there is no God; we are the words; we are the music; we are the thing itself. And I see this when I have a shock.

[…] It proves that one’s life is not confined to one’s body and what one says or does; one is living all the time in relation to certain background rods or conceptions. Mine is that there is a pattern hid behind the cotton wool. And this conception affects me every day. I prove this, now, by spending the morning writing, when I might be walking, running a shop, or learning to do something that will be useful if war comes. I feel that by writing I am doing what is far more necessary than anything else.

– Virginia Woolf, Moments of Being

Orbito-frontal cortex seems […] to be the area of the brain that bestows a quality we may refer to as free will.

Yet even this heady endowment does not make consciousness complete. Its most important component is not the ability to plan, or choose, or follow through a strategy despite the insistent urgings of our unconscious brain to chase each passing shadow. Rather it is the intuitive sense of meaning that binds our perceptions into a seamless whole and makes sense of our existence.

Can that, too, be pinpointed?

Astonishingly, it seems that it can. Meaningfulness is inextricably bound up with emotion. Depression is marked by wide-ranging symptoms but the cardinal feature of it is the draining of meaning from life. People in a severe state of depression fail to see life as a unified pattern and start instead to see it as a fragmented, incomprehensible sequence of pointless events. Social bonds are severed, normal activities seem purposeless – everything seems to be falling apart. By contrast, those in a state of mania see life as a gloriously ordered, integrated whole. Everything seems to be connected to everything else and the smallest events seem bathed in meaning. A person in this state is euphoric, full of energy and flowing with love. They are also in a state of high creativity — the connections they see between things, which are often invisible or overlooked by others, are often used by them to make new concepts.

The area of the brain that is most noticeably affected in both depression and mania is an area on the lower part of the internal surface of the prefrontal cortex – the ventromedial or subgenual cortex. This […] is the brain’s emotional control centre. It is exceptionally active during bouts of mania, and inactive (along with other prefrontal areas) during depression. The connections between this region and the limbic system beneath it are very dense, closely binding the conscious mind with the unconscious, and this configurement is probably what gives it special status: it is, if you like, the part that best incorporates the whole of our being, making sense of our perceptions and binding them into a meaningful whole.

– Rita Carver, Mapping the Mind

Wandering Wom(b)an

Hysteria is a wandering. Hippocrates believed the womb, in a wayward state of dis-organ-isation, produced all manner of symptoms. The body with wayward (if not wholly without) organs is denounced for its chaos, excluded on the (un)grounds of its disordering. Its rambling path is pathologized.

Why the womb? Why not the mind? Why not the body? Why not everything everywhere all at once?

Cixous and Clément write that the “hysteric unties familiar bonds, introduces disorder into the well-regulated unfolding of everyday life, gives rise to magic in ostensible reason.” Or better yet, through Woolf’s example, the ‘hysteric’ – as a manic-depressive archetype reclaimed (manic in her free will; depressive under patriarchy) – is a conduit for expressing the art of living (at the surface). She must climb up to it, out of the occulture where patriarchy has confined and maligned her. It is the most arduous of ascents, and if it tends to end in disaster, after which she leaves behind an alienated matrix of unpublished reminiscences, then woman is categorised for her incompleteness all the more intensely:

every sorceress ends up being destroyed, and nothing is registered of her but mythical traces. […] This ambiguity is expressed in an escape that marks the histories of sorceress and hysteric with the suspense of ellipses.

Ellipses are not lapses, so much as they are points of slackening and tightening; dynamic points of anxious tension; of undecidability. “The complete situation […] manifested in the expressive stagings that surround the sorceress and the hysteric”, Cixous and Clément continue, include: “rituals of beginning, of setting in motion, of waiting expectantly for the attack.” The wandering wom(b)an hangs, from moment to moment, in (pregnant?) pauses. What is required in order to break from the laborious pause into action?

To emerge from this coupling of remembrance and reciprocal persecutions, to arrive in the present and no longer return to pantomimes of the past, it will be necessary to get out of the look, to leave the exchange of words, and to break up the circus of transference.

In short, a complete – or appropriately incomplete – elision of the psychoanalytic act. One that breaks free of the house and its couch; one that opens the door, shuts it behind her, and enters the world, enquiring not simply into the individual psyche, wrapped in cotton wool, but into the world and into nature, identifying with it even.

Freud himself, in first meeting Woolf, may have recognised this tentative relation between them. Perry Meisel recalls how:

Newly settled in London in 1939, Freud presents Woolf with a narcissus when she and Leonard Woold come to pay their respects at his home in Maresfield Gardens […] Freud presents Woolf, not with a diagnosis, but, through the agency of a flower, with a mirror. The narcissus was a reflection less of Freud’s belief that Woolf was self-absorbed than of his belief that they shared a common shop.

Their shared shop may be overstated. Woolf was certainly familiar with psychoanalysis, and Meisel argues that she was much closer in affinity to Melanie Klein, but she maintained a critical distance from its particulars. Freud’s gift of a narcissus may well have been recognition of that far more fundamental relation: a mirror, yes, but not in which Woolf saw only her reflection, but like Narcissus himself, the flows and faults, the blooming and wilting, of nature itself.

It is for this reason that Woolf’s writing are not so much psychoanalytic as they are schizoanalytic. Better a hysteric out for a walk across the surface of the world than the bound sorceress submitting herself to an exorcism of her depths. She confides not in her analyst, but in her public with her pencil. She writes in and of the world.

This is a conscious strategy; a programme of emotional engineering. Although Woolf has often been posthumously diagnosed with ‘manic-depressive disorder’, might we argue that it was only depression that led to her world becoming disordered? And wasn’t the world itself already empirically so? She lived at a time of war. She socialised with all manner of bohemians and libertarians who lived lives more free than hers often felt capable of becoming – since she loved women and relished the company of gay men. But when she writes of writing, is this not an expression of an auto-affected ‘mania’?

The writing is not itself ‘manic’, but a honing of ‘mania’ – which was, for her, ‘being’. Writing is the second-order ordering of a life experienced and felt deeply and serenely. Manic order counters depressive disorder. She contains, within herself, all the arrows of the pharmakon – pierced in equal measure by poison and cure; capital and nature; men and women; inside and outside. The oscillations and the curdling – these are not neat binaries – are nonetheless dizzying. The greater challenge is withstanding the tumult and the shock that each collision produces and contains and exceeds.

Withstanding the Shock

Cracks appear at the surface. Tectonic movements shake the ground beneath one’s feet. Chthonic tremors are not thought of for their depth, but for their surface effects. Sometimes, these effects take a while to make themselves known.

“Of course all life is a process of breaking down,” writes F. Scott Fitzgerald,

but the blows that do the dramatic side of the work – the big sudden blows that come, or seem to come, from outside – the ones you remember and blame things on and, in moments of weakness, tell your friends about, don’t show their effect all at once. There is another sort of blow that comes from within – that you don’t feel until it’s too late to do anything about it, until you realize with finality that in some regard you will never be as good a man again. The first sort of breakage seems to happen quick – the second kind happens almost without your knowing it but is realized suddenly indeed.

What is to be done? The worst outcome is identifying the shock and letting it engulf the self. Fitzgerald travels “a thousand miles” on his flight out “to think it over”; “to think why I had developed a sad attitude towards sadness, a melancholy attitude towards melancholy, and a tragic attitude towards tragedy – why I had become identified with the objects of my horror or compassion.” Such identification, he adds, “spells the death of accomplishment.”

Lenin did not willingly endure the sufferings of the proletariat, nor Washington of his troops, not Dickens of his London poor. And when Tolstoy tried some such merging of himself with the objects of his attention, it was a fake and a failure.

To survive necessitates making “some sort of clean break.” It is “something you cannot come back from; that is irretrievable because it makes the past cease to exist.” Here, the writing takes over as an impersonal form of continuum – a flatline: “A concurrent trajectory of 0-redundancy, 0-dimensionality, and absolute (or continuous speed/ curvature (vortex)), defining a smooth space in itself (intensity = 0).”

Line break. New paragraph.

“I must continue to be a writer because that was my only way of life, but I would cease any attempts to be a person”, Fitzgerald continues. He believes that he succeeds, eventually: “I have now at last become a writer only. The man I had persistently tried to be became such a burden that I ‘cut him loose’…”

The Globe in the Wood

Outside the Globe in St John’s Wood, men in identical gilet jackets all drink Guinness and talk shop. A man is moving “to the other side” of some sort of financial profession – buying instead of selling, or vice versa, I suspect; it is unclear and unimportant.

People hang on his every jargonistic utterance. Other conversations swell and lull around him and I. “Money-on-money exchange.” “How many women do you hit on usually?” “What advice would you give?” a lone woman in his group asks. “You guys don’t need any advice from me: you’re all professionals.”

Who is he? Who are they? What is this language they are speaking? The language of Capital and its exchange. He is grey. So are they. He has lost his face in it; it is unbecoming. He is all too recognisable as an archetype of his sex, his class, his profession. He becomes identical to whatever category he belongs to, to the extent he loses all character. He briefly mentions his children, but in the next breath they have gone, and so have I. He is a man and nothing else, nothing more.

The Guilt of Being

I walk down the canal at dusk to be here. It is bitterly cold. I have taken up an invitation from Wassim to attend a panel discussion at The Showroom, hosted by Kodwo Eshun and Anjalika Sagar, in conversation with Bahar Noorizadeh, Max Haiven, Adam Haj-Yahia and Lama El Khatib. The topic of discussion is violence and the sacrificial in the world of finance.

It has been a long time since I was last present for this kind of conversation. I am alienated by it at first, before old names and topics of horrifying intrigue from a decade ago return to the forefront of my mind, dusted down. I start manically making notes.

Noorizadeh’s work treats capital as fiction, as myth, as theology, Eshun explains. Homo economicus comes to infer “the image of an economic God, in whose image we are created.” Walter Benjamin’s argument that historical materialism needs its own theological sense – a notion of ‘faith’ in its processes – is mentioned repeatedly. Peter Thiel’s interest in the Catholic writings of René Girard are a core concern also.

Eshun speaks of the “technocapitalist matrix of continuum mutation”. Haj-Yahia relates this to capital being “ultimately concerned with the value of time”. In vying for economic equilibrium, it inevitably brings about the cancellation of the future. For that reason, an eschatological conception of time inflects the left’s materialist view of history. All that is missing is its true theological bent, ejected for a secularism that produces its own kind of stasis.

What would a Marxist theology look like? (Some will be familiar with Deptford’s ‘Red Rector’, who has much to offer in this regard.) The contemporary (cosmic) right already have their own version of theology, the panel argues, thanks to Thiel and the influence of Girard’s Catholic capitalism.

“Has the market made me an angel?” is the question that Haiven asks, ventriloquising Thiel. It is not for nothing, he continues, that techbros use theology to understand not just the world but also themselves, since theory alone does not cut it. Noorizadeh explains how the late Hayek also takes an interest in “esoteric unknowns” and suggests that it is precisely the capitalist’s theological ‘faith’ in the Market that transforms the Market itself into “a new godhead”.

The horror of this godhead is that, on the altar of capital, capitalists themselves make all kinds of sacrifices. Colonialism, gentrification, globalised class war – these are the vectors along which the sacrificial logic of capitalism takes place. Politics alone, El Khatib argues, cannot fully capture these metaphysical aspects of the capitalist system. This sacrificial logic is “non-rational, non-utilitarian”. It is driven by the exploitation of excesses, producing sacrificial zones (the Global South), sacrificial bodies (black, brown, proletarian, et al.), etc.

AI, in particular, is producing new zones of digital sacrifice and carving out new abattoirs in the labour market. Whether AI works or doesn’t work, whether it transforms the world as promised or fails to do so, it does not matter. Preparing for its arrival regardless generates more sacrificial opportunities that will aid the continued valorisation of capital. To clear the way for the new, whether it blows up in our faces or not, generates value. Indeed, it is very possible to produce value through processes of elimination. Israel, in ‘eliminating’ the Palestinian people and their lands, has demonstrated this openly.

The problem for the left, as ever, is how to respond to, overturn, or subvert this sacrificial capitalism. One way, Haj-Yahia suggests, is to reverse the formula – something we are already seeing across the world, whether in Gaza or closer to home. Via a Shia theo-logic, he transposes ‘sacrifice’ for ‘martyrdom’. The ‘martyrdom’ of the many to benefit the few – as has unfolded throughout Israel’s genocide – is the theo-logic of capitalism laid bare on a horrifying scale. But for the Palestinians themselves – and protestors around the world supporting their cause – what we see (and even participate in) is a martyrdom of the ‘self’ for the sake of the many. He invokes the martyrdom of Imam Husayn and carefully opposes this to the individualisation that is enforced on more capitalist conceptions of the self.

“The question of the Self is not separate from the question of the Other,” Haj-Yahia insists. It is the dialectical kernel of all social bonds. The idea that Self and Other are separate, irreparably so, is where capitalism inflicts so much of its psychic damage. Indeed, “the generosity of the self is its sociality”, and here ‘the self’ is poignantly separated (as a concept) from ‘the subject’, ‘the individual’, the liberal ‘person’, etc.

There is excess here too; the self itself is excessive. The excesses of sacrifice and martyrdom crack us up. ‘Faith’ in something bigger than ourself – revolution or the market – humiliates reason. How are we to hold everything together? Indeed, how do we make things whole?

Theology becomes necessary in order to account for the excess, that is, for what exceeds the self, its conceptions of the world, and its disasters. Betrayal lurks behind every corner. On the one hand, Haj-Yahia argues, it would be a betrayal to not at least try and think about the metaphysical violence of capitalism and of genocide. We must try to understand it somehow. But to succeed in thinking this violence, or otherwise claiming to – holding it in our hands and saying, ‘This is what it is, this is how it functions, this is why’, conceptualising it, providing it with a reason, reducing it to some shorthand – that too would be a betrayal. We would discount its fundamental excess, its fundamental incomprehensibility. In this way, the true nature of the violence exerted upon the self and the other, upon the social, forever escapes us.

In the pub afterwards, talk of ‘the self’ continues. Sagar, reflecting on time in India, watching Israeli and Germans alike prostrate themselves before cult leaders in order to ‘transform the self’, argues that their Western-liberal-fascist logics fundamentally pervert the journey of the crack-up, and so they are doomed to fail on their clichéd excursions into their New Age ‘Hearts of Darkness’.

The point that they all missed, she says, is the core of many Eastern theologies: “cleansing the self of the guilt of being”. The point is not to destroy the self, but free it from the infections of language-virus, liberal Protestantism, and capitalist commodification; to let the self be itself, becoming itself, unperturbed by all white-magic ontologies of confinement.

On the walk home, back the way I came, a fixation of Ida’s I Know About You returns, dramatizing the ambivalences of selfhood amidst the guilt of social being. Flawed, endlessly stupid, incapable of the perfection that is desired, but making progress, learning to live with a broken heart – broken across scales: in two, in community, in the world.

Explaining One(‘s)-Self

How does writing for oneself mediate the blows delivered to the self? How does writing reckon with the ‘problems’ of being and non-being, and the processes of becomings that happen in between? How does writing intuit a sacrifice beyond economies? Or intuit a self within a social milieu?

“It is very hard to ‘explain oneself'”, Deleuze says. Nevertheless, the “art of constructing a problem is very important: you invent a problem, a problem-position, before finding a solution.” This does not happen in dialogue or conversation, nor even in lonesome self-reflection, nor simply through objection. “The aim is not to answer questions” at all, he adds enigmatically – “it’s to get out, to get out of it.” That is, to get out of the question.

“We think too much in terms of history, whether personal or universal. Becomings belong to geography, they are orientation, directions, entries and exits.” So, Woolf’s shocks at / in the world are encounters through which she escapes the question – whatever question – that is trifling her. There is no final solution, no final terminus (not even in death). “For as someone becomes, what he is becoming changes as much as he does himself.” This takes work: the work of becoming.

When you work, you are necessarily in absolute solitude. You cannot have disciples, or be part of a school. The only work is moonlighting and is clandestine. But it is an extremely populous solitude. Populated not with dreams, phantasms or plans, but with encounters. An encounter is perhaps the same thing as a becoming […]. It is from the depth of this solitude that you can make any encounter whatsoever. You encounter people […] but also movements, ideas, events, entities. All these things have proper names, but the proper name does not designate a person or a subject. It designates an effect, a zigzag, something which passes or happens between two as though under a potential difference: the ‘Compton effect’, the ‘Kelvin effect’.

The Fisher-Function… As Deleuze writes of Bergson: “in him there is something which cannot be assimilated, which enabled him to provide a shock, to be a rallying point for all the opposition, the object of so many hatreds”.

As I walk through London, reconnecting with friends not seen for a decade, my encounters with Mark haunt me everywhere. For many years, outside the occasional ‘talk’, ‘lecture’ or ‘presentation’, I have managed to escape all talk of Mark Fisher in meatspace. It gave me space to grieve and then breathe. Now I am back and I am working on his archive again. I feel, in fact, like I am working with him again. He is in every friend I re-encounter. It provides me with an opportunity to once again describe him otherwise, between pop-culture and occulture; “this strange fact of working between the two or us. […] This had nothing to do with a school, with processes of recognition, but much to do with encounters.”

There are another encounter. It echoes in the crack-up. I don’t want to write about it – not anymore; it is not kind or fair – but I write around its effects. It is inevitable. It is the task of ordering that counters the disordering. It involves action, thought, love, feeling, writing – necessarily.

Deleuze is quick to emphasise that ‘getting out of it’ does not mean “the world, mysticism, or art, or else that it is something rather sloppy because we avoid our commitments and responsibilities.” On the contrary, “to flee is not to renounce action: nothing is more active than a line of flight.” For Woolf, it is perhaps getting out of a room of one’s own – which is nonetheless a material necessity, especially for woman, who may feel only like a lodger in the master’s house – that allows her to exit the ‘problems’ she wrestles with there. But the two are not diametrically opposed either. Woolf both writes flows and walks among them. As she writes and walks, she creates: “everything is departure, becoming, passage, leap, daemon, relationship with the outside.”

The flight is thwarted eventually. “What is it which tells us that, on a line of flight, we will not rediscover everything we were fleeing? […] How can one avoid the line of flight’s becoming identical with a pure and simple movement of self-destruction?” Was Woolf’s capacity for taking shocks overstated? This can “only be understood on the line”, Deleuze argues: “the dangers which are courted, the patience and precautions which must go into avoiding them, the corrections which must constantly be made to extract the line from the quicksands and the black holes.” This is the most uncomfortable position to occupy, and the one position in which any work gets done. “Being in the middle of a line is the most uncomfortable position.”

Does writing become a scaffold? A guard rail? Ariadne’s thread? Deleuze thinks so:

It is possible that writing has an intrinsic relationship with lines of flight. To write is to trace lines of flight which are not imaginary, and which one is indeed forced to follow, because in reality writing involves us there, draws us there. To write is to become, but has nothing to do with becoming a writer. That is something else. […] The becomings contained in writing when it is not wedded to established order-words, but itself traces lines of flight are quite different. You might say that writing by itself, when it is not official, necessarily comes into contact with ‘minorities’ who do not necessarily write on their own account, about whom no one writes either, in the sense that they would be taken as object, but, on the contrary, in which one is caught up willy-nilly, from the fact that one is writing.

Woolf is a notable example:

Even women do not always succeed when they force themselves to write like women, as a function of a future of woman. Woman is not necessarily the writer, but the minority-becoming of her writing, whether it be man or woman. Virginia Woolf forbade herself ‘to speak like a woman’: she harnessed the woman-becoming of writing all the more for this.

This is the fundamental function of the traitor. Just as Woolf stole – but did not plagiarise – the form of biography in Orlando (with biography then viewed as a masculine endeavour: Great Men writing about Great Men): “What other reason is there for writing than to be traitor to one’s own reign, traitor to one’s sex, to one’s class, to one’s majority? And to be traitor to writing.” To do so, one “has to lose one’s identity, one’s face, in it […] disappear, become unknown.” One has to stop being a subject, an individual, a person – one has to become a self.

As Woolf writes in The Waves: “But how describe the world seen without a self? There are no words.” The self is cluttered by all of its non-being. It is wrapped up in cotton wool. Burn it away and cleanse one’s self of the guilt of being and non-being. Become your self. It takes time. It is a time beyond value; it is invaluable.

Street Haunting

‘But it was a mistake, this extreme precision, this orderly and military progress; a convenience, a lie. There is always deep below it, even when we arrive punctually at the appointed time with our white waistcoats and polite formalities, a rushing stream of broken dreams, nursery rhymes, street cries, half-finished sentences and sights – elm trees, willow trees, gardeners sweeping, women writing – that rise and sink even as we hand a lady down to dinner. While one straightens the fork so precisely on the table-cloth, a thousand faces mop and mow. There is nothing one can fish up in a spoon; nothing one can call an event. Yet it is alive too and deep, this stream. Immersed in it I would stop between one mouthful and the next, and look intently at a vase, perhaps with one red flower, while a reason struck me, a sudden revelation. Or I would say, walking along the Strand, “That’s the phrase I want”, as some beautiful, fabulous phantom bird, fish or cloud with fiery edges swam up to enclose once and for all some notion haunting me, after which on I trotted taking stock with renewed delight of ties and things in show-windows.’

– Virginia Woolf, The Waves

Phantom Limb

The Way is limped through.

I rise at 5am, awoken by the children upstairs crying; I doze, drowning them out with louder thoughts. My leg still feels strange.

By 10.30am, I have managed to arrange a doctor’s appointment to have the leg examined. “Any pain?” No, only a fading limb, becoming-phantom. The diagnosis: some inflammation or impingement of the peroneal nerve. It is as if the bottom half of my right leg alone has been sapped of all energy. I describe it to Doctor Wong as another – a friend in a coma; a friend who won’t listen. I walk, and it says, ‘I would prefer not to’. Three days ago, she fell asleep and now she won’t wake up.

Ironically, it is likely the result of having sat awkwardly for too long, the doctor tells me. This is despite walking 200 miles over the course of October. I am two-thirds of the way back to Newcastle.

It haunts me, this leg. It was around this time twelve or thirteen years ago when my mother had the same complaint. She fell on a woodland walk and that was when they discovered the spinal catastrophe, pressing itself against her nerves. That is when we discovered her alcoholism, unrelated. That is when psychosis took her, unexplained. I feared, for a moment, that the same thing was happening to me now.

The Day

It is November 3rd. I walk to the Tate but am unmoved by anything within it. I get my earlobes pierced just to feel something. I look at all the images of Christ on the cross and innumerable wounded saints and weeping angels in the National Gallery. I look at the bags under my eyes in public bathrooms. Like Badiou’s figure of the human, I am morose without a project. This languidity, this depression – strange how unfamiliar. This emptiness.

I rest with Virginia by the Thames. There are no waves. A graffito on the guard rail reads, ‘Free Lewie’. I think of Amu and Rhae and Joy. The river is still. “I think I am the field, I am the barn, I am the trees; mine are the flocks of birds, and this young hare who leaps, at the last moment when I step almost on him.” I am the brave pigeon wanting to share in human warmth, I am the scatty rat darting out of sight, I am the tourists who stop bewildered at everything, I am the blown leaves on the surface of the mirrored grey sky, I am the Uber boat. “I cannot be divided, or kept apart.” I hate Andy Burnham. “I hate linoleum; I hate fir trees and mountains.” Let me sit here and vape blueberry nicotine postmodern fog. “Let me now fling myself on this flat ground under a pale sky where the clouds pace slowly.” The planes cut above me. “The earth hangs heavy underneath me.” I think sometimes I am a woman. “I think sometimes … I am not a woman, but the light that falls on this gate, on this ground.” I am the phantom foot, which is no longer mine. I am the shoe it drags along reluctantly. “I am the seasons, I think sometimes, January, May, November; the mud, the mist, the dawn.” What I take is solace in sadness. “What I give is fell.” I am the scowl, the grumble, the yawn, the tut, the kissed teeth. “I cannot float gently, mixing with other people.” I am never hungry. “Now I am hungry.” I am 34 and so is Rembrandt, cocksure on the gallery wall; I am haggard in the bathroom mirror.

Street Haunting

In Foyles, I find Virginia’s unfinished autobiography and her essays on liberty:

No one perhaps has ever felt passionately towards a lead pencil. But there are circumstances in which it can become supremely desirable to possess one; moments when we are set upon having an object, a purpose, an excuse for walking half across London between tea and dinner.

Phantom limb or not, I walk 16.4 kilometres with a vape in one hand and a pen in the other. 21,985 steps, by the time I return to the kitchen table to type up my scrawl. Reading Virginia with a pot of tea, I recall the impulse to buy a new notebook and pen before meeting Col at Frith Street Gallery some weeks ago. I pass by her father’s exhibition on my way to the Tuesday night meeting, where I cry in front of all the strangers in loving detachment. I walk home through the cold dark after.

As the foxhunter hunts in order to preserve the breed of horses, and the golfer plays in order that open spaces may be preserved from the builders, so when the desire comes upon us to go street rambling the pencil does for a pretext, and getting up we say, ‘Really I must buy a pencil,’ as if under cover of this excuse we could indulge safely in the greatest pleasure of town life in winter – rambling the streets of London.

It is a pleasure. The pen, the camera, the phantom foot in front of its other. “We are no longer quite ourselves … we shed the self our friends know us by and become part of that vast republican army of anonymous trampers, whose society is so agreeable after the solitude of one’s own room.” If only. There is so little that is agreeable about London beyond the light and St Paul’s and the artificial geologies. The body, however, does become more agreeable. In its movement, it forgets itself — and perhaps a little too literally, odd foot. It bothers me, then it doesn’t.

The shell-like covering which our souls have execreted to house themselves, to make for themselves a shape distinct from others, is broken, and there is left of all these wrinkles and roughness a central oyster of perceptiveness, an enormous eye. How beautiful a street is in winter!

The eye roves over the thousands of faces. It casts itself over concrete. The enormous eye only stops for oddities. All else is a blur.

The eye is not a miner, not a diver, not a seeker after buried treasure. It floats us smoothly down a stream, resting, pausing, the brain sleeps perhaps as it looks.

Or it should.

We are in danger of digging deeper than the eye approves; we are impeding our passage down the smooth stream by catching at some branch or root. At any moment, the sleeping army may stir itself and wake in us a thousand violins and trumpets in response; the army of human beings may rouse itself and assert all its oddities and suffering and sordidities.

How strange it still feels to live in central London. How alien. To leave the world behind, one has to only throw oneself further into it. It disappears as you disappear. There is no depth on the street; “be content still with surfaces only”. What Stoicism is this?

Skirting on the Surface

“Sense appears and is played out at the surface”, Deleuze writes in Logic of Sense, “in such a way that it forms letters of dust. It is like a fogged-up windowpane on which one can write with one’s finger.” The surface is where the Stoic lives. “The philosopher is no longer the being of caves, nor Plato’s soul or bird, but rather the animal which is on a level with the surface – a tick or louse.” It is a “‘perversion’, which at least befits the system of provocations of this new type of philosopher – if it is true that perversion implies an extraordinary art of surfaces.”

This is how Woolf, philosopher of the surfaces of England, involutes ‘hysteria’. The hysteric, write Cixous and Clément in The Newly Born Woman, “resumes and assumes the memories of others”. Michelet and Freud, they continue, “[b]oth thought that the repressed past survives in woman; woman, more than anyone else, is dedicated to reminiscence.” She, “whose body is transformed into a theater for forgotten scenes, relives the past, bearing witness to a lost childhood that survives in suffering.”

Woolf remains in the present, at the surface. “A new type of esoteric language is formed here which is its own model and reality”, Deleuze adds. “Becoming-mad changes shape in its climb to the surface … and the same thing happens to the dissolved self, the cracked I, the lost identity, when they cease being buried and begin, on the contrary, to liberate the singularities of the surface.”

What happens at the surface? We “see things without attachment, from the outside,” Woolf writes in The Waves. We “sense that a burden has been removed; pretence and make-believe and unreality are gone, and lightness has come with a kind of transparency, making oneself invisible and things seen through as one walks – how strange.”

The surface is not bare. It curdles, fogs, and the last thing written on the window returns ghostly, “as on the first day of creation, but acquainted here with grief”. “What torments one is the horrible activity of the mind’s eye … the terrible pounce of memory, not to be foretold, not to be warded off”. One does not walk to walk away. Everything is arranged at the surface. Not simply memory, but the semio-blitz of signs, each one an affective trigger, a rabbit hole, a hare under one’s foot, each one revealing itself, scattering, darting, concealed before but concealing nothing from itself. It is there, out of concealment, that serenity arrives. “It is the effort and the struggle, it is the perpetual warfare, it is the shattering and piecing together – this is the daily battle, defeat or victory, the absorbing pursuit.” This is the surface. It is satisfactory:

the atmosphere of common sense and tobacco; old women clambering into the third-class carriage with their baskets; the sucking at pipes; the good-nights and see you to-morrows of friends parting at wayside stations, and then the lights of London – not the flaring ecstasy of youth, not that tattered violet banner, but still the lights of London all the same; hard, electric lights, high up in offices; street lamps laced along dry pavements; flares roaring above street markets. I like all this when I have despatched the enemy for a moment.

Image
Image
Image
Image
Image