Fly Wild Swans: My Mother, Myself and China

Create post

David Bennett

Tamara and I went to St Martins In The Field Church here in central London to listen to Jung Chang who wrote Wild Swans: Three Daughters of China, first published in 1991.

She has written a sequel, about the period after the death of Mao and how she sees the current Chinese leadership.

I have not read Wild Swans, and I don't know how much of what I am writing here is in the book.

So now to her talk.
She described how her father was high up in the Communist Party.

When she came to England as an exchange student to study English after Mao died and the country opened up a bit, her first impression was that England was a classless society because there were apparently no guards around important residences.

In contrast, in China, her father had guards around his house.

That is, her father was important until he wrote a letter to Mao, opposing what he saw as the tragedy of human suffering that was caused by the Cultural Revolution.

She didn't say that a specific event was the turning point, but she described herself how even gardens were not immune from the Cultural Revolution.

Gardening, she said, was viewed by Mao as a bourgeois endeavour. And the gardener at the school she attended was publicly humiliated and beaten, with a sign hung around his neck, because he raised flowers. And she and her fellow young communists had to go out and uproot the grass in the lawn and cut all the flowers down.

And this may be just me making a connection, but long after she moved to London, an intruder got into the house without apparently making a forced entry, and cut all the blooms and leaves and stems off the flowers and bonsai trees on the balcony of the house. And the intruders carefully took away everything that they had cut off so only stumps were left.

It doesn't seem much of a stretch to see the actions of the intruder as a warning over what she later wrote and felt about pulling up the grass and destroying the flowers in her school.

So her father wrote to Mao objecting to what was happening in the Cultural Revolution, and he was imprisoned and eventually rehabilitated after Mao's death, but it shortened his life.

Her father told his wife, Chang's mother, that she should divorce him so that she wouldn't face repercussions along with her husband over the letter he intended to send to Mao. But she refused to do so, and so she herself was humiliated; forced to kneel on broken glass while all the people in the community jeered and threw rocks at her.

And it was because she was associated with a man who had objected to the inhumanity of the Cultural Revolution in which 40 million people starved to death.

They starved because Mao was selling grain to Russia, and then when China fell out with Russia, China was selling grain to the United States. China was selling grain the people needed but he had a greater prize in mind - military and industrial technology to make China the world's number one superpower.

When she and her husband were writing the biography of Mao she interviewed Kissinger. Once they got over the pleasantries and he understood that she had had access to the transcripts of Kissinger's meetings with Mao, he was candid and agreed that felt that Mao was a philosopher.

I too think of Mao as a philosopher; as a man who through a little Red Book, the Cultural Revolution, the Mao clothing, took all the small disparate fiefdoms in China and welded them into one country.

In doing so he was the author of the death of millions but for him that was the price that I would have to pay for bringing China into its rightful place in the world.

There are different ways to look at it and I know that some people will be appalled and some not.

I remember in the book, Darkness at noon how the captive describes his captor's view of humanity - how he saw one man as one million men divided by one million.

It means of course that he saw no value in an individual but only in the collective.

But as we know now, Mao did not enjoy that poor peasant lifestyle for himself and he had his own desires that he could exercise because he had the power.

Chang came to London and her only image of the West before she came was from her textbooks where a Londoner was a poor man who lives in the capital of fog.

But she had some idea of privilege because she had seen The Sound Of Music, and so she had a very strange picture of what England might be.

When she arrived she immediately felt at home and she was determined that she would have a good time. That was the number one goal.

She was sexually free, and it suited the mood of the times. She was desirable and exotic. But in order to avoid being cast as a communist doll, she told people she was from South Korea.

And she eventually wrote Wild Swans and when China opened up and people were able to come and go relatively freely she was still able to go back to China despite the negative view of communism that she had written about in Wild Swans. But, she said, now that Mr. Xi is in power, she doesn't feel she can go back and that Xi might imprison her because he is a tyrant like Mao.

What can I say about her? She's got a wickedly lovely sense of humour, a sense of humour for the realities of life, and not to be swept away with ideologies.

Now she has written Fly Wild Swans: My Mother, Myself and China - the sequel to Wild Swans and everyone at the talk had a copy they could take with them. The cover is red, and it struck me that we all left with a little Red Book.

Jeff Bezos May Turn Out To Have Been Wise

I wrote this on Medium in October 2024, and now that Musk has spectacularly failed to bring in the Midterm votes for Trump, people are wondering what more bad things he might be in for. Well, he hitched his wagon to what he thought was what the country needed, and there are still millions who agree with him, and that should not be forgotten.

For those who believe in people power, as in a lot of small people rather than a few big people, then the arc of this American election may turn out to be the perfect story.

The perfect adventure story is when the young huntsman sets off to find the prize, and is faced with a villain who at first appears to have been defeated and then comes back stronger. And then in the end is defeated. And that’s how the story will be seen to have gone if Kamala Harris wins.

If that happens, then everybody who votes for her and a lot of those who didn’t vote for her will breathe a sigh of relief. The story will have been the very best story it could have been.

This is a stronger story than if Harris had come on the scene and Trump had simply faded.

This way everybody has a satisfying feeling in the pit of their stomach, in their hearts and their minds and in their vision of the future. Back from the brink.

And of course the baddie in the story is Trump. But the even more evil baddie is the man, Musk, who represents what happens when someone who is good at business thinks they’re also good at politics.

In the end instead of Musk motivating a lot of individuals he was simply seen as a very rich man who pushed or tried to push the election one way.

I think we’ll look back and we’ll see that Jeff Bezos who’s been accused of failing to endorse either candidate will seem to have been the wiser person. Unlike Musk, he doesn’t have a political agenda. And when called, because he is big and important, he said no.

In time, and unlike Musk he will be seen as a person who saw that he is a businessman. He runs businesses. The day he starts getting into politics is the day he’ll lose his way.

In the 1930s the Communists in Germany thought they were going to win big in the elections. Inflation was through the roof and Germany’s social fabric was pulled to breaking point with riots. Trotsky told the Communists in Germany they were fooling themselves. When danger lurks, he said, the population runs to mummy’s apron strings.

It’s not a parallel because America is not on the ropes economically, but the world is uncertain and dangerous. So the question is — which is mummy? I think it is the good old, same old system that Harris represents. Trump is too wild, to uncertain in uncertain times.

If people need to translate that into something they can say they voted for, then two issues stand out. Reproductive rights and immigration. Well the next couple of weeks will see how well I predict this presidential race, which is a clear win for Harris.

So what Harris failed to do in the last election, has come to fruition in the Midterms, and all is right with the world again. Or so say some.

What We Love Will Ruin Us

In an issue of the print magazine The Week, for which my wife Tamara has a subscription, I noticed this in the ‘Memorable Quotes’ section:

“The surest way to work up a crusade in favour of some good cause is to promise people they will have a chance of maltreating someone. To be able to destroy with good conscience, to be able to behave badly and call your bad behaviour righteous indignation’ — this is the height of psychological luxury, the most delicious of moral treats.” Aldous Huxley, quoted in The Spectator

Quite a quote.

A statement about man that we mostly want to pretend isn’t true.

But dig under the ideology of this man or that and we find that the ideology serves the man and not the other way around.

We might hear a person in his innermost being say “Give me an ideology that fits my needs and desires — for me, not for the benefit of anyone else.”

Yes, quite a quotation, and naturally it interested me to know exactly where Huxley said it, in what book or article or pamphlet or interview.

So I googled for the origin of the quote.

Most search results that came up — and there are a lot of them — do not give an origin for the quote but merely repeat it.

Some reported where the quote was quoted, but still not where the quote originated.

Some, however, say it is in Huxley’s book Crome Yellow.

I bought the Kindle version of the book for pennies and searched.

And the quote is not there.

I found an online HTML version of Crome Yellow from Project Gutenberg and searched it as well, just in case. And the quote is not there.

I searched for bits of the quote, picking out salient words such as ‘maltreatment’ and ‘righteous indignation’ and ‘moral treats’.

Nothing.

I thought maybe it was in Huxley’s novel ‘Island’ — so I bought a Kindle copy and searched.

Still nothing.

So I asked Bard — Google’s AI tool — and this is what it says:

The quote “To be able to destroy with good conscience, to be able to behave badly and call your bad behavior ‘righteous indignation’ — this is the height of psychological luxury, the most delicious of moral treats.” is attributed to Aldous Huxley, but the exact source of this quote has been debated.

Some sources suggest that it comes from Huxley’s 1932 novel “Brave New World,” while others claim it is from his 1962 essay collection “The Doors of Perception.” However, neither of these works contains the exact phrase in question.

The earliest known appearance of the quote is in a 1966 book called “God Running” by John S. Hall. Hall attributes the quote to Huxley, but he does not provide a specific source.

It is possible that Huxley did utter the phrase at some point in his life, but there is no definitive evidence to prove it. The quote has certainly been widely circulated since the 1960s, and it is often used to criticize hypocrisy and self-righteousness.

So did Huxley ever say it at all?

Is it not indicative of the modern world and the casual brushes with the truth that The Week copied the quote from The Spectator and used it and neither publication checked whether the quote was in fact a quote.

The Spectator describes itself in its ‘About’ as follows:

The Spectator was established in 1828, and is the best-written and most influential weekly in the English language. Our writers have no party line; their only allegiance is to clarity of thought, elegance of expression and independence of opinion. Our writers’ opinions range from left to right, their circumstances from high life to low life. None make any pretence at being impartial: our motto is “firm, but unfair”.

We are a member of IPSO, the independent press regulator, and abide by the Editor’s Code. We also uphold strict standards of accuracy.

But Wait, There’s More

If this was all I have to say, then I would think I had made a poor effort.

But here is something that Neil Postman wrote about Huxley and George Orwell, that is worth reflecting on in these times. And I leave you with this:

On Orwell and Huxley’s vision of our future/present:
Orwell feared those who would deprive us of information. Huxley feared those who would give us so much that we would be reduced to passivity and egoism. Orwell feared that the truth would be concealed from us. Huxley feared the truth would be drowned in a sea of irrelevance. Orwell feared we would become a captive culture. Huxley feared we would become a trivial culture, preoccupied with some equivalent of the feelies, the orgy porgy, and the centrifugal bumblepuppy.
As Huxley remarked in Brave New World Revisited, the civil libertarians and rationalists who are ever on the alert to oppose tyranny “failed to take into account man’s almost infinite appetite for distractions.”
“In 1984”, Huxley added, “people are controlled by inflicting pain. In Brave New World, they are controlled by inflicting pleasure.”
In short, Orwell feared that what we hate will ruin us. Huxley feared that what we love will ruin us. ~Neil Postman

By the way — did Neil Postman actually write this? Yes he did — in his book Amusing Ourselves to Death.

Is It A Good Idea To Praise MI6

I saw an article in The Week magazine that read:

A good week for MI6, which is the strongest foreign intelligence service in Europe, according to a peer review by 60 professionals from 25 countries. In particular, the Secret Intelligence Service was praised for its expertise in recruiting high-level moles and penetrating ruling elites in China, Russia, Iran and Turkey.

Forgive me, but aren’t its successes supposed to be kept secret?

I’d be worried about the 60 professionals who publicly named MI6 and effectively outed it.

Are We All Destined For This?

I came across a review of a book that mentioned a person who was described as a cultural theorist.

His name is Paul Willis (born 1 April 1945 in Wolverhampton, England) and he is described as having spent his life working as a sociologist, ethnographer, and professor (Keele University and Princeton University.)

He says this

"We are most deeply embedded in our culture when we are at our most natural and spontaneous... as soon as we think, as soon as we see our life as parts in a play, we are in a very important sense, already, one step away from our real and living culture"

So when a person is not in the culture but removed from it, where is he? I am tempted to say that a man does not rescue himself from imprisonment, but that is getting ahead of myself. But I am saying it because otherwise I might go on a different track and lose my own position, or what position I have to the extent that I have it.

To continue - when a person is 'one step away from our real and living culture' - what and where is he?

Can he ever go back to be unconsciously in the experience? I think not.

Can he go back to be consciously in the experience? And if so, what is that state of being?

Are we all destined for this?

Snowflakes or Progress


Image

As of 1 November, new potential sign-ups to the free version of Pagecord have to be invited. Previously, anyone could sign up, but according to the site owner, the site has had a lot a spammers signing up so they could use the Pagecord as a stepping stone to get viewers to come to a site they host elsewhere. If I were on the receiving end of that I wouldn’t like it: No one likes being used.

Anyone with a premium account has codes to give out to people they know so that person can use the invitation to get access.

Well, I joined and had a free account and then a paid account before all this blew up, and very early on, at the beginning when Olly built the site.

He has taken a lot of stick for using AI for some of the coding. It’s hard to please everyone. 

I happen to like Pagecord and I can’t see me getting annoyed over how the site was constructed when I would not be able to do that work myself. People are funny. Well, not funny really. They just love to get offended.

I was wondering about the progress of mankind. People are more individual than they used to be. That is probably in line with the move away from tight, rural communities. In the city, people have their antennae out because they don’t know who is around them. Nearly everyone is a stranger, and that turns a person into a stranger too.

So I was wondering whether we are all snowflakes now, hypersensitive when there is no need, or whether we have actually become more sensitive and that is a good thing – or at least not a negative thing – because we are all tuned in more to each other?

Image

Cambridge Botanical Garden

The photos here are from a visit to the Botanic Garden in Cambridge that I visited with a friend this past week. It's November and the leaves are still on the trees. A magnolia had large buds on it. What are they going to do? Will they hang on until the Earth turns? Will they be nipped in the bud if there is a cold spell?

Are we feeling a bit discombobulated because the planet it not behaving in the regular way we like, and are we reading into this the early signs of the coming age of a catastrophe?

Music Tours at Fenton House, Hampstead

Last week we visited Fenton House in Hampstead and signed up for a tour to learn about the harpsichords there.

The house is owned by the National Trust and it is not a particularly large and not that special or interesting as old houses go. The Garden is particularly interesting but the real interest is in the fact that there are more than 20 harpsichords in the house.

How they came to be there is a story in itself involving bombing raids in World War II, but that’s another story.

The real reason for going to Fenton House is to join a music tour to hear about the history of these harpsichords and to hear them played.

It’s not every day that one gets to hear music played in a small room by a professional on an instrument that is two or three hundred years old.

If you go then I recommend you arrive early to be sure to get a place on the tours. The house is old and the rooms are small, so not more than about twelve people can be on a tour.

Just go to the house and sign up on the day. The house is not open every day, and noteven every day when the house is open. So look up Fenton House search engine of your choic; go to the website and look for the days when the tours are being led.

Tours are led by volunteer musicians. There is no public list of the musicians who lead the tours, but we were very lucky to be on a tour that was led by a man named Nicholas Lane, who is a harpsichordist, pianist, organist, teacher and composer.

I cannot speak about the other tour leaders, but if they are of this standard, then the tour you take will be something really special And memorable.

Paid Influencers

Because I take photos and want to read about cameras and lenses, I subscribe to Reid Reviews. Mr Reid reviews what he wants to review, and he comes at the whole thing from the point of view of his needs and desires as a photographer who photographs gatherings, state fairs, people he knows around where he lives - that kind of thing.

He doesn't have any advertising on his site. You pay a subscription and you get in. And he doesn't have a comments section: He writes and you read.

And he doesn't 'use' affiliates to promote his website. If he did, and if I were an affiliate, then I would be caught between mentioning his site here because I value his reviews, and valuing the money I might make if someone were to click the affiliate link. Without that worry, a person can feel cleaner in their motivation.

Perhaps influencers and affiliates will be banned by some future Government, citing the damage to the psyche of the influencer or affiliate by being caught in this cleft stick of split motivations. After all, we are caught in the prison of our motivations all the time. At least those who have not thrown in the towel are aware of it and struggle with it daily.

So, now to Reid Reviews, where in the 30th September review of 90mm rangefinder lenses for the Leica M EV1 he made a side comment about paid advertisements and the effect it has on the bias of review sites. And in among that he said

"I still find it somewhat amazing that we now have a media role called "influencer" which is usually referred to without irony."

It is 'without irony' that stopped me, as it might have stopped you.

Reid references a John Oliver piece. Oliver puts a searchlight on the way news outlets present advertising disguised to look like news. Presenting ads as news is called native advertising. It’s deceptive. It works if the reader is deceived.

As Oliver says, it is our fault because we are not willing to pay for news - and this is the price we pay. Being of a suspicious mind, one might claim that the very reason that news was presented free on the Web for years was as a back door way to introduce native advertising.

In that scenario, the groundwork is laid slowly, over years, until we the consumers believe we are entitled to free news. And then the trap is sprung - and we are the product.

Oliver actually made his observations twelve years ago. Today, several news outlets - at least in the UK - are only available on subscription. But the native advertising still runs even on subscription. We are basted delicately for years until we have become tender and now we accept the inevitable.

Of course, it doesn't matter that much if all you are trying to sell me is a titanium chopping board on the premise that it doesn't harbour bacteria or micro-plastics, or wood slivers. But when you try to sell me something ideological under the guise of fact, that's a different story.

The Trees, The Trees - Ricoh GR III

I shot these with a Ricoh GR III. which was not the main camera I was using on the day. My main camera was a Canon EOS R6, which is a full-frame camera. It weighs more than twice as much as the Ricoh, and that is without a lens. Put a lens on it and it is three times the weight or even four times the weight of the Ricoh.

And for landscapes, the shallow depth of field that is the main advantage of the larger full-frame sensor, doesn't really have any advantage. Of course the larger sensor has more light gathering power - but in decent light that is not really a make-or-break for a smaller sensor.

Image
Image


Image
Image

Why Books Are Different

DSF5179.jpg.webp
Lost Sheep

I was reading an article by Herman Martinus about his love of reading and how literacy has declined. Herman is the coder, publisher, and general factotum of BearBlog, a platform not unlike WordPress or Pagecord.

There’s irony there, is there not - lamenting that no one reads books while being the architect of a blog platform.

Because I was on the street walking to the tube when I read Herman's article, I used WhisperBoard on my phone to write the following, which is my experience of reading books for pleasure. I should preface it by saying that I read many articles on a subject with which I am very involved, but that's a different matter. It is almost like work.

And I read about photography and buy books of photographs taken by the photographers whose work I like and from whom I want to learn.

But when I was growing up in the North of England, we had very few books in the house. I remember one about the Troubles in Northern Ireland about which I knew nothing and had absolutely no context to understand the novel. It was written in the vernacular and the word police was spelled POLIS, because that’s how people in the book spoke. When I think back I have no idea why we even had the book the book in the house, bearing in mind that it was about the only book on the shelf and none of my family was Irish.

My mother took me to Oakwood library when I was very young, and she told me how she would borrow six books at a time from her local library when she was a girl. So that was an encouragement for me to read and I thought the whole province of reading was something desirable.

But that makes it all the more surprising that we didn’t have books in the house. If she read when she was a child, why did my mum stop reading? All I ever remember her reading was Radio Times, Woman’s Own, and Woman’s Weekly. But she watched the news and she was up on what was happening around the world.

I remember once asking her what time would be a good time to phone her and she said, jokingly, three in the morning because she would be up watching the news.

Then, when I was at Grammar School, our English teacher really opened my eyes and the eyes of the people who were interested. He introduced us to everything from Rabelais to Kafka and Thomas Mann.

And I could read a book in a short time and then for some reason over the years, I’ve slowed down and I’ve been reading The Wild Sheep Chase for about a year. 

Plus, I have a pile of other books which I’ve hived off a bigger pile and put next to the bed so that when I’m sitting there, I don’t have to think that there are 20 books but only four books that I will read at some point.

But I’ve slowed down so much. And similarly when walking I’ve slowed down, not that I intentionally slowed down, but I noticed that now that people who are younger than I am are passing me. They are faster unless I make an effort and somehow I don’t want to make the effort. And it’s the same with reading. I don’t want to speed on. I enjoy the pace at which I read. But I also think that I ‘should’ be reading at a faster pace than a book a year.

Why Books Are Different

The thing about a book is that it stops when you stop reading. Unlike a play or a film, it does not dictate the pace. It does not continue and drag you with it. Instead, it sits patiently waiting for you.

That said, I have to get a bit of a move on with the Guy Burgess book because I am going on a spies walk later in October.

This may be why I don't join book clubs. I don't like the forced pace, even against the promise of good company.

Spies

I read Donald Maclean’s British Foreign Policy Since Suez 1956-1968 about Britain’s attempts to balance its relationship with Europe and the United States. Maclean talks about the changing fortunes of Britain and the history of the uneasy straddling between Europe and the United States that Britain has been pursuing since the Second World War.

Donald Maclean was a British civil servant and one of the Cambridge Five spies who spied for Russia from the 1930s, and in his case until 1951. 

Until I read Roland Philipps’ biography of Maclean I thought Maclean was a minor civil servant.

In fact he was very high up in the service, privy to all kinds of secrets at the highest level, and in line for an appointment as British Ambassador to the United States.

Maclean wrote British Foreign Policy Since Suez 1956-1968in 1970 when he was living in Moscow.

Hodder and Stoughton published the book in the UK with Foreign Office approval.

The book is a diatribe against the ultra-nationalists as he calls them - people who don't give a sh-t for anyone as long as they control the muck heap.

Something else I learned from Maclean’s book was that there was an agreement between Britain and the United States that the atomic bomb would only be used with the consent and agreement of both countries. In plain English, Britain gave approval to the use of the atomic bombs dropped on Hiroshima and Nagasaki.

I found a 2013 article in Japan Times which said that according to papers recently declassified by the U.S. National Archives and Records Administration, Britain supported the use of atomic bombs by the United States against Japan in World War II and did so about a month before the first one was dropped on Hiroshima.

So now, on to Guy Burgess, and accounts I have read of Burgess suggests he was flaky when things got difficult. I am reconciling that with the picture of the man in Guy Burgess: The spy who knew everyone. But then I am not far into the book. What I have got so far is that he was bright, took chances, took advantage of people (which he could do in the climate of homosexuality being illegal) and, in the end, was destructive. More than that, that he had a moral conscience that dictated what he did, but that conscience had to live with the other side of his personality that loved risk for its thrill.

Notting Hill Carnival

I was out buying stuff today and Tamara told me Notting Hill Carnival was on, so I went. Or rather I walked with thousands of others from Paddington. I didn’t get to see the parade, but I saw a lot of people.

On the way there a notice by a police van said that facial recognition software was being used. On the way back I looked in the van and a man was scanning images, and outside a man in handcuffs was shouting out to his friends – ‘I don’t know why’ and ‘It wasn’t my fault’. I wonder how good the software is? 

There were a lot of police along the road – several hundred at a guess, and I was thinking what a time consuming waste it is for the most part. I guess, I should say maybe. I should say that without the big police presence all hell would break loose. is that really what Notting Hill Carnival is like - barely suppressed violence?

Where to start?

Start with Claudia Jones, born in Trinidad in 1915. As an eight-year-old she moved with her parents to New York. She grew up in Harlem and became a Marxist and a significant Communist Party figure out of the racial prejudice she saw.

In 1955, during the anti-communist repression of the early Cold War she was imprisoned for nine months and then deported under the Alien Registration Act of 1940 for her political activities.

Her offence was to 'advocate the overthrow of the US government by force or violence, to organise a group advocating such overthrow, or knowingly to belong to such a group.'

She was deported from the US to Britain because Trinidad was then a British colony. Without that fact she would have been deported to a Communist Bloc country as others were.

Now living in London, in 1958 she founded the West Indian Gazette, that reported on discrimination in employment and housing, reported on racist attacks and on international anti-colonial politics.

Then, in what became know as the Notting Hill race riots, white gangs attacked mostly people from the Caribbean over several days beginning on Bank Holiday August 1958.

Jones wanted a public response to assert the community's identity and celebrate Caribbean culture. Its dual purpose was to bring people together and to send out a message saying we are here, and the first festival was held in January 1959.

It was held indoors, but it couldn't be contained and the next major organiser was Rhaune Laslett who turned the Carnival into something bigger.

She was local, born in London, and a social worker and activist The National Portrait Gallery describes her as the "principal organiser of the Notting Hill Festival, that evolved into the Notting Hill Carnival."

Claudia Jones meanwhile, died of a heart attack in London on Christmas Eve 1964, and is buried in Highgate Cemetery next to Karl Marx.

In the 1970s relations between the police and young black Londoners were extremely bad. It was the time of the 'sus law' that allowed the police to stop and search anyone they thought might be guilty of an offence, and it was almost entirely young black people who were stopped and searched. Being on a public street and stopped while all around you passers-by were looking and judging, was a major factor in the relations with the police.

The 'sus law' was was part of section 4 of the Vagrancy Act 1824 that allowed prosecution of a 'suspected person or reputed thief' found loitering in certain places with intent to commit an arrestable offence.

After the Brixton riots in 1981, for which the 'sus law' was found to be a major contributory factor, the offence was abolished by section 8 of the Criminal Attempts Act 1981.

But in 1976 the law was still in effect and at the 1976 Carnival there was a major confrontation with the police. The fact is though that the Carnival grew to the size it is today, and over the years there have been hundreds of arrests, dozens of stabbings and some fatalities.

Now the numbers are coming through for this year's Carnival and I was wrong by a big margin for the numbers of police. In fact, 7.000 police were deployed.

Notting Hill Carnival
Notting Hill Carnival
Notting Hill Carnival
Notting Hill Carnival

Professor Jason Arday: A Life In Tatters

Professor Jason Arday (JA)

It is difficult to write this without seeming to be piling more abuse on a man who is now dead and unable to defend himself. In fact, my feeling is that the real story is about Cambridge University and how they came to appoint him. And similarly for previous institutions that appointed him.

The allegation is of course that these institutions fell over backwards in their determination not to see JA's colour for fear that they would be prejudiced or seen as prejudiced. Consequently that fear blinded them to his lack of truthfulness and his lack of ability. And in that they failed to uphold the pursuit of truth.

Moreover, when questions were raised, their first instinct was to circle the wagons and claim that prejudice motivated JA's critics. And in that too they failed to uphold the pursuit of truth.

By the admission of his contemporaries and those who appointed him, JA was autistic and vulnerable. In that case it is at least a question as to whether he should have been appointed to the Cambridge professorship. And this leaves aside the claims that he plagiarised work, that he was an outrageous fantasist, and that he used race himself to silence critics.

Rather the question of whether he should have been appointed is simply on the basis that a vulnerable man, as he was described, should not have been appointed to oversee students.

Disentangling the threads

Did JA plagiarise?
Was he a fantasist?
Did he suffer racial abuse?
Was his behaviour representative of a victim?
What do those who knew him most closely say of his character?
Why was there such intense media interest?

The mayor of London, Sadiq Khan, was reported in the Guardian Saturday 15 August 2026 as saying: "I'm devastated for the family and friends of Jason Arday. He faced an unacceptable public hounding and campaign of abuse. "Jason Arday was the victim of a pernicious public shaming that other people in his position simply wouldn't have faced. His death was a tragedy, but once again it should be a wake-up call for all of us."

Sadiq Khan made that statement on Friday 14th August on X (formerly Twitter) and the quote in the Guardian is entirely accurate.

On the same day, Professor Simon Baron-Cohen (professor of developmental psychopathology at the University of Cambridge and director of the university's Autism Research Centre and a Fellow of Trinity College) said in a Radio Times interview that he had spoken with JA on the morning he died, and

"He really wasn't coping. I mean, as has just been described, he was being subjected to relentless scrutiny, including ridicule, discrediting absolutely every detail of his life, and he wasn't coping with the loss of his career, the loss of his reputation, and he felt he couldn't go on. I want to say that he was an incredibly kind and gentle and caring and generous man, but he's been portrayed in the media, both the traditional media and social media, in the last month as a plagiarist and a liar and a fraud. At the heart of all of this was a man who'd been diagnosed in childhood with disabilities that included autism and language delay and learning differences. So he was, by definition, I'm choosing my words carefully, he was a vulnerable child, a vulnerable teenager, and a vulnerable adult. So he needed and deserved safeguarding and support and reasonable adjustment every step of the way."

On July 31, 2026, Professor Simon Baron-Cohen posted on X:

"In 2014 we published the first large-scale study of suicidality in autism, subsequently widely replicated, revealing that 1 in 4 autistic people have planned or attempted suicide. That's why I'm very concerned about the impact of the media coverage on Professor Jason Arday who is autistic. He has been accused of plagiarism and he was cleared of any academic misconduct following a rigorous investigation by Liverpool John Moores University. And yet he continues to be systematically discredited over every detail of his life, daily. We should of course always investigate plagiarism to protect academic standards. However, I cannot stand by and watch when an autistic man is on the ground and the kicking continues. This is relentless bullying of a vulnerable autistic man and raises safe-guarding issues. It's time to stop."

According to Jolyon Maugham of The Good Law Project Maugham was approached in July 2026 by 'a senior Black academic' and subsequently the Good Law Project set up a petition under the heading Stand In Solidarity With Jason Arday, that came off the back of the following letter signed by more than thirty academics.

"We, the undersigned, are appalled by the sustained and malicious attacks on the academic integrity of Professor Jason Arday.

Entirely false allegations of plagiarism were made against Professor Arday and referred to two universities. Investigations have found no evidence whatsoever of wrongdoing. The relevant academic journals also found no basis for the claims.

Yet despite these unequivocal findings, rightwing media have attempted to smear Professor Arday's reputation and undermine his career. That should concern everyone who believes in academic freedom, fairness and due process.

It is difficult to ignore the question of motivation. When a distinguished Black academic is repeatedly subjected to baseless allegations after being fully exonerated, it signals there is an attempt to undermine Black people who hold positions of influence.

Professor Arday, a working class Black man, became the youngest Black professor in the University of Cambridge's history. His remarkable journey, scholarship and leadership should be celebrated, not overshadowed by campaigns built on allegations that have been comprehensively rejected.

Professor Arday has contributed to public life for many years, building a distinguished record of charitable and community service. This latest smear campaign and the spread of misinformation are deeply alarming -- not only because of the impact on one individual, but because of the message they send to aspiring Black and Brown young people who seek to attain positions of leadership.

The demonisation of Professor Arday, and recently on Misan Harriman, risks creating a chilling effect, signalling that success and public service may be met with hostility, misrepresentation, and disproportionate scrutiny.

We stand in unwavering solidarity with Professor Arday. We call on universities not only to defend academic freedom and robust scholarship, but also to confront racism wherever it manifests itself, whether overtly or through persistent attempts to discredit exceptional Black academics.

There can be no place in higher education for campaigns that weaponise baseless accusations to damage reputations and careers. Universities must ensure that excellence is protected and that every scholar is judged on the merit of their work, not the colour of their skin."

You will not find Professor Baron-Cohen's name in the list of signatories because, as The Sunday Times reported 8 August, several Cambridge academics who had originally signed the letter subsequently removed their names from the list of signatories. They included Simon Baron-Cohen, Sonita Alleyne (President of Jesus College) and Ricardo Sabates Aysa (Professor of Education and International Development), and Dame Ijeoma Uchegbu, President of Wolfson College.

In May 2023 Professor David Harris, Professor Emeritus at University of St Mark and St John at Plymouth contacted JA, Cambridge University, and Liverpool John Moores University about troubling similarities between passages and data in JA's work and in other published work.

In response, JA reported Harris to the police for racial harassment.

Harris subsequently brought in Professor Martyn Hammersley, an emeritus professor of educational and social research at the Open University, who examined the material and wrote to Cambridge in May 2023 saying that he believed there was substantial plagiarism.

In 2025, Jack Grove of Times Higher Education (THE) was investigating allegations concerning plagiarism by JA. Grove sent JA questions in the ordinary course of seeking his response before publication. Not receiving a reply In pursuing his story Grove emailed JA four times with a series of questions about his academic record.

JA engaged solicitors Carter-Ruck to warn THE not to publish and THE ultimately did not publish the investigation at that time.

JA also complained to the police about Jack Grove, alleging racial harassment, and in consequence Gove was subjected to a four-month police investigation for harassment that was eventually dropped as meritless.

THE continued to gather evidence, and by July 2026 had assembled a 63-page dossier of textual comparisons and that the proposed story concerned alleged plagiarism in JA's PhD and journal articles.

Another thread in this matter is the work of Nathan Cofnas. His work is explicitly a rebuttal of a right-wing argument that Jews spread views that are embraced by the world - from Freud to Marx - the purpose of which is to undermine non-Jews sense of position and confuse them so that Jews can retain control of the world. Cofnas's rebuttal starts from Stamford University's evidence of IQ among different groups and from that says that this entirely disinterested evidence simply shows a truth.

On a personal note, intelligence does not equate to value, or to the depth of a person's humanity.

That aside, Cofnas who too was at Cambridge, used JA as an example of someone who would not have been appointed but for DEI and that the DEI movement was detrimental to the pursuit of truth.

On July 21st 2026 he published a post in which he listed JA's fantasist claims and the plagiarisms that he had found by running JA's texts through AI plagiarism tools. He seems to be the first person to have done this. This is his post:

https://substack.com/@nathancofnas/p-207415162

Cofnas posted a link on X (formerly Twitter) to his article, stating that JA's plagiarism was an “open secret at Cambridge University” and within days his post on X had 5,850 likes, 1,020 reposts and 839 replies and was presented (although not necessarily read) more than one million times.

The day after publication, other Substack users were circulating it, and The Daily Sceptic included the article in its daily news round-up, directly describing the allegations.

A day later, the Daily Telegraph ran an article entitled 'Cambridge's diversity poster boy in plagiarism row: Youngest black professor in university's history is subject of bitter argument between academics', reporting that:

Until now, the row had been happening away from public view – but the publication of a blog this week, which features a side-by-side comparison of Prof Arday’s thesis with that of another student, has brought it out into the open.

An analysis of Prof Arday’s PhD thesis for The Telegraph identified more than 100 passages that are identical or nearly identical to a 2009 PhD thesis by Paula Zwozdiak-Myers, a Brunel University student.

Racism At Large

The Higher Education Statistics Agency (HESA) data records that there were 270 Black professors in Britain in 2024/25. That number represents about 1% of the professoriate. In 2023/24, 24% of UK academic staff were from ethnic-minority backgrounds.

In Cambridge, Black professors were 0.4% of its professoriate in 2025. Two are recorded as having been subjected to a concerted racially motivated campaign. One is JA and the other is Professor Priyamvada Gopal, also of Cambridge, who sparked a campaign against her after making racially charged comments about whiteness.

The London Proof House: Still Testing Guns After Nearly 400 Years

The London Proof House
The London Proof House

There are two proof houses in England, one in London and one in Birmingham. If you had asked the question one hundred years ago you would have got the same answer.

When the trigger on a gun, rifle, shotgun, pistol, revolver or whatever is pressed, the sensitive detonator in the cartridge sets off the explosive powder in the cartridge, and that ejects or sends the bullet or pellets out with force. As we know, even a small bullet can travel two miles when it is shot out of a barrel.

So as you can imagine, the pressure inside a gun is huge. And the gun and the barrel have got to withstand that pressure over and over again.

A proof house is where firearms and gun barrels are tested, inspected, and stamped with proof marks to show they are safe for use, and it is illegal to sell or transfer a firearm that doesn’t have a valid proof mark.

Proof houses are established by Act of Parliament, and in days gone by, by Royal Charter. The London Proof House is operated by the Worshipful Company of Gunmakers, incorporated by Royal Charter in 1637, and carries out the statutory proof of small arms under the Gun Barrel Proof Acts.

Testing involves firing the guns in a special chamber, to make sure that they are safe, and do not have any defects that causes them to blow up. 

When I passed the proof house, I wondered whether the name on the building was current. I was thinking that maybe it was an old sign, maybe the proof house had moved or maybe there weren’t any proof houses any more, So I rang the buzzer and a man came to the door and I asked him. And yes, it is still a proof house. I think I sounded amazed when he told me.

It didn’t strike me at the time, but looking at the photo above on the screen it struck me that the two very tall posts with cameras were placed there specifically because of the nature of the building.

And in the photo below, you can see another example of London being surrounded by skyscrapers like buildings from another planet.

Commercial Road, London
Commercial Road, London

The Lack of a "Sanity Check Step" In AI

I asked Gemini to compare the physical dimensions and magnification of the EVF in two cameras. One camera has its EVF in the top left corner and the other has the EVF at top centre. in fact, it turns out that the physical dimensions and magnification of the two EVFs is identical, so there is nothing to choose between them. But Gemini added in that the camera with the EVF would be better for a person who is left eye dominant, otherwise the photographer's face would be smushed against the back of the camera.

That's wrong. It would be better for a right eye dominant person because then the whole of the face to the left of the right eye would be away from the camera body.

I told Gemini I thought it was wrong and asked:

Question: Are you sure you have this correct? If the EVF on the A7C II is in the left top corner of the camera back and I put my right eye to the EVF then surely this statement is wrong "the entire camera body sits across your face".

Gemini reassessed, saying "You are completely right, and I had that backwards—thank you for catching that!..." and then went into detail.

So then I asked:

Question: How was it possible for you to have made the 'and I had that backwards' error? This is not a criticism, I am puzzled because the logic was not complex?

And this is the interesting bit, and the reason I am writing this at all. Gemini answered

That is a fair question! The short answer comes down to how my architecture processes Spatial Reasoning and Perspectives versus formal logic.

While the spatial geometry itself was simple—a camera extending to the right with two human eyes spaced a few inches apart—here is why that slip happened:

1. Linguistic Pattern Matching vs. Physical Simulation

I don't actually "see" a physical camera or possess a mental body with a left and right eye. Instead, I generate responses based on patterns learned from vast amounts of text.

In camera review articles, forum discussions, and YouTube transcripts, there is a very common recurring phrase: "Rangefinder-style EVFs let you keep your other eye open to scan your surroundings."

Because that advice is frequently repeated in the context of rangefinder cameras, my internal system pulled that general concept into the explanation. But instead of pausing to physically simulate the exact orientation of a human face against a top-left viewfinder, I filled in the explanation by echoing standard phrasing—which accidentally tied the benefit to the wrong eye.

2. "Left Camera" vs. "Left User" Confusion

Spatial directions are notoriously tricky in text processing because "left" changes depending on the reference frame:

  • Camera frame: The EVF is on the left side of the camera body (when looking at the back).
  • Face frame: When a right-eye user looks through it, the camera body extends to the right side of their face.

It’s easy for language models to accidentally flip these reference frames during sentence generation—swapping "left eye" for "right eye"—if the underlying spatial map isn't explicitly calculated relative to the user's nose.

3. The Lack of a "Sanity Check" Step

When humans think, you can easily picture a camera in your hands and tap your own right eye to test the logic in half a second. My generation process runs sequentially—token by token—so unless I am specifically forced to map out coordinate points step-by-step before generating the text, I can fall into logical traps created by common phrasing habits.

It was essentially a classic case of relying on a generalized concept rather than executing a spatial simulation. Pointing it out was helpful—it forced the system to stop, map the geometry relative to the face, and correct the physical layout!

My comment

That's how accidents happen. And it cannot be put down to input error from me or whoever might ask the question about EVF sizes and magnification. It cannot be because of poor phrasing from the questioner. I didn't ask it which EVF placement would suit a particular person. This error arose out of Gemini's giving me its own additional helpful but wrong information.

Marilyn Monroe

The exhibition at the National Portrait Gallery in London is on now, and ends 6 September 2026. I snapped these with my phone to show the many faces of Marilyn Monroe.

Tamara and I came out of the exhibition feeling positive towards Marilyn and what she gave out to the world.

The texts below are quotes and descriptions from the exhibition.

Marilyn Monroe

With Marilyn, the love affair was not posing for the camera. It was love for her audience – her public – who eventually would see the photo. She loved the public, her fans, more than any one human being.’
Sam Shaw

I now live in my work and in a few relationships with the few people I can really count on. Fame will go by, and, so long, I’ve had you fame. If it goes by, I’ve always known it was fickle.
Marilyn Monroe

She was much more of a partner than I’d expected. The first hour or two I had an idea of what I was after. I had all kinds of imagery floating around, and she was picking up on it, performing it all!
Bert Stern

Fashion photographer Bert Stern (1929-2013) was commissioned to photograph Marilyn Monroe by Vogue: it was one of the star’s long-held ambitions to appear in the magazine. The session took place in across three days at the Hotel Bel-Air in Los Angeles, where Stern made more than 2,500 images, aided by props such as sheer scarves and jewellery. Music and champagne contributed to the relaxed atmosphere of the sitting.

Reviewing the contact sheets and transparencies, Monroe crossed out several images that she disliked.

The urgency and expressiveness of her interventions rendered the rejected images particularly compelling.

Her apparently harsh critique was the the subject of considerable fascination when they were published after her death, and in the decades since.

Vogue did not consider the nude images suitable for publication, and commissioned a second session focussing on high fashion, which were published in the magazine a month after Monroe’s death, accompanied by a moving tribute from the author Joan Didion.

Life magazine, 3 August 1962 Interview with Marilyn Monroe by Richard Meryman, photographs by Allan Grant Since its publication this article has taken on a particular resonance as Monroe’s final interview, published just days before the news of her death emerged.

Monroe was used to media exploitation, and she urged Meryman to ensure that her words would be taken seriously: 

What I really want to say: That what the world really needs is a real feeling of kinship…We are all brothers. Please don’t make me a joke. End the interview with what I believe!
Marilyn Monroe

‘She romps, she squeals with delight, she leaps on to the sofa. She puts a flower stem in her mouth, puffing on a daisy as though it were a cigarette. It is an artless, impromptu, high-spirited infectiously gay performance. It will probably end in tears’
Cecil Beaton

George Barris’s joyful photographs of Monroe on Santa Monica beach, taken just days before she died, were initially published in the UK – first in the Daily Mirror and later in Town magazine. In his article, the journalist, David Robinson wrote: When she died, everybody tried to explain her, which would have interested her a lot, because she was all her life trying… to explain herself.’
Terence Pepper Collection