Mastodon
· A new essay every Monday Sign in Join the Commons
Dr Robert N. Winter For Critical Thinkers
This week’s essay Monday 16 November 2026

The Paper and the Question

Qantas's governance review faulted its board for not asking and its management for not telling, in the same paragraph. Neither side needs to be dishonest for an issue to go unraised: each can simply wait for the other to raise it.

This week’s conversation On the Subject of Leadership
Episode · Wednesday 11 November 2026

The People Who Don't Have to Be There

Gilbert Lorquet leads donors, volunteers, and directors who could all walk away. As chief executive of the NORTH Foundation and chairman of Football NSW, he explains what that teaches about leading the people who are paid to stay.

The reflection · Thursday 12 November 2026 Leadership

A Gift Must Be Received

Almost two-thirds of what the NORTH Foundation raised in 2024–25 came from bequests, from people who could not be thanked or instructed. Organisations that run on goodwill show plainly what every organisation depends on, and what a payroll hides.

Series in progress

The Two Agendas

Image The latest · Part 3 The Paper and the Question Qantas's governance review faulted its board for not asking and its management for not telling, in the same paragraph. Neither side needs to be dishonest for an issue to go unraised: each can simply wait for the other to raise it. The Commons Monday 16 November 2026
The parts
Part 1

The Orphan Issue

Monday 2 November 2026
Part 2

The Interested Voice

Monday 9 November 2026
Part 3

The Paper and the Question

Monday 16 November 2026
Part I

The Orphan Issue

Free to readComing Monday 2 November 2026
Part II

The Interested Voice

The CommonsComing Monday 9 November 2026
Part III

The Paper and the Question

The CommonsComing Monday 16 November 2026
Part IV

The Director’s Agenda

Inner CircleComing Monday 23 November 2026
Part V

The Executive’s Agendas

Inner CircleComing Monday 30 November 2026
All series
The index · eight arguments, eight parts of the book

Filed by argument, not only by topic

Organisations substitute legible proxies for the unglamorous work of judgement. That single swap produces both the “saviour” they should not have hired and the wasted talent they did. Topics tell you what a piece is about; arguments take you on the journey.

Every argument
Image IThe Saviour and the Hammer One pathology, two symptoms: the manufactured saviour and the wasted artisan. 3 essays · newest, The Emperor's Tailors Image IIThe Aperture Organisations do not assess the person in front of them; they assess the proxy, and the proxy is always cheaper, safer, and often as not—wrong. 15 essays · newest, Character Is Not a Training Need Image IIIThe Guardians The people positioned to say the unwelcome thing are systematically disciplined out of saying it—and the disciplining never appears in any meeting minute. 17 essays · newest, The Paper and the Question Image IVThe Theatre When words stop carrying consequences, people stop being accountable for what they say, and then for what they do. 6 essays · newest, How Corporate FOMO Replaced Strategy with Stagecraft Image VThe Permanent Pilot AI is not a new failure; it is the old failure—signalling over substance, acquisition over capacity—conducted at unprecedented speed and expense. 18 essays · newest, Raising the Sea Level Image VIThe Artisan The artisan, not the tool, builds the house—and artisanship is a profession, not a side hustle for the technically gifted. 7 essays · newest, The Instrument Is Rarely Blamed Image VIIThe Proxy Mind The proxy does not stop at the hiring panel: busyness passes for work, the metric for the mission, the forecast for judgement—and every such failure begins in a single mind. 21 essays · newest, The Director Who Reads the Summary Image VIIIBuilding the House The slow, unglamorous, compounding work that the saviour was hired to spare everyone having to do—yet the only thing that was ever going to work. 19 essays · newest, A Gift Must Be Received
On the Subject of Leadership

Conversations with people who carry responsibility

The conversations that shape organisations usually happen behind closed doors. These are held out loud—on leadership, management, and governance, as they are actually discussed.

All episodes
The latest conversations
Wednesday 11 November 2026

The People Who Don't Have to Be There

Gilbert Lorquet leads donors, volunteers, and directors who could all walk away. As chief executive of the NORTH Foundation and chairman of Football NSW, he explains what that teaches about leading the people who are paid to stay.

Wednesday 21 October 2026

Reality Versus Aspiration

A search shows what an organisation would like to be; an assessment shows what it is. Malcolm Duncan on four decades of appointments, the briefs he declines, and why charisma is the most overrated quality in an executive.

Wednesday 7 October 2026

Doing Less with More

My guest this week is Tim Newbold, founder of OKR Quickstart, who has spent a decade watching goal-setting frameworks meet real organisations, and who argues that when they fail, the fault is almost never in the framework.

The archive

Recent essays

A new essay every Monday, and the podcast’s written companion every Thursday.

The full archive
Governance

The Interested Voice

AMP promised the regulator an 'entirely independent' report, yet sent it through 22 drafts first. The Post Office hired independent accountants, then dismissed them once their findings turned. Where every speaker is presumed to argue from interest, the honest voice is absorbed or discounted.

The Commons Monday 9 November 2026 · 11 min read
The Commons

One essay a week, and the argument to which it belongs.

Free, by email, references included. Every essay not written for the Inner Circle alone, and each one in audio.

Unsubscribe whenever you like. Nothing is passed to anyone else.

The Inner Circle

Patronage, not a subscription.

For readers who want to keep the work going: essays written for the Inner Circle alone, every essay and conversation in a private feed, and the Canon each month.

A$100 a year, or A$15 a month.

Now playing
—
0:00