Maybe I'm just not au fait with current trends?
Monday, 20 July 2026 03:51 pmI took a punt on a crime novel that the mysteries reviewer of the Literary Review seemed very keen about.
And not only did it fall into that category we were recently discussing, of mysteries/crime novels/thrillers, where one suspects the writers would really like to just be writing a novel about these people/this community/this setting but these days you can't do that, you have to have a body in there somewhere and some detection going on -
It was way clunky.
I was shocked! shocked! to see that it is traditionally published by a firm which has, or used to have, a significant reputation (Faber & Faber), because clearly they are not doing much on the editorial side these days -
Even the very pro-the-book reviewer mentioned pointed out that there is a massive and absolutely basic blooper about property law which has significance to the plot, such as the plot is, which one would have thought would have got picked up by a competent editor on first reading the ms, let alone with a decent copy-edit. This was not the only blooper, some of which may be charitably attributed to that thing which one has observed too much since word-processors became a thing, spell-check says it's spelt correctly. It does not pick up that it's the wrong bloody word in context.
Okay, it is apparently no 4 in a series and maybe this has built up enough cred that readers will take for granted that Our Detective is a cop, because I found the procedural details a little vague and misty, but that may be due to having misspent significant parts of my young years reading procedurals?
I don't read a lot of modern cosy-ish crime - because this struck me as really fairly cosy - but is viewpoint-hoping within scenes now A Thing? - i.e. we start in what appears to be standard tight third person, and then suddenly we have viewpoint of Other Person in the scene and then flip back. Maybe I am a fuddy traditionalist who thinks you sticks with the viewpoint you came in with.
Possibly there is a hope that the sequence will get took up and made into a TV series as actors might well flesh out the rather flat characters....
I am the more annoyed as the reviewer put me onto Sally Smith, so this was a particular disappointment.









